ParentingBanter.com

ParentingBanter.com (http://www.parentingbanter.com/index.php)
-   Child Support (http://www.parentingbanter.com/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   Discrimination against CP Dads in Canada by the CRA (http://www.parentingbanter.com/showthread.php?t=35645)

[email protected] November 4th 05 03:45 AM

Discrimination against CP Dads in Canada by the CRA
 
Since I have been seperated and divorced, I have had my tax return
audited 60% of the times I have filed. Each time they ask for proof
that my son lives with me, plus other personal information. The Canada
Revenue Agency insists that the checks are random, but the math doesn't
work for me. If they randomly check less than 1% of returns, then
checking mine 60% of the time is not a statistical anomoly, it clearlly
indicates specific targetting.

I suspect that the computer checks divorced, male, child deduction -
this must be wrong.

I am looking for any other custodial fathers in Canada that have
experienced similar discrimination by the Canadian Revenue Agency.
Please email me.

Thanks,
Dave Flewitt


SpiderHam77 November 5th 05 10:32 PM

Discrimination against CP Dads in Canada by the CRA
 
Iam one of those fathers in Canada that has been audited. Divorced..
having my son live with me full time. I remember the one question they
asked was why I was not claiming child support as an income.

I looked at them with my Accountant, and told them I don't claim it,
because I'm not getting it. And then they asked where my Ex-Wifes file
was and why she had not filed. I told them they would have to speak to
her, and that she currently lives in Ireland, so you may have a little
trouble forcing her to file one.

But as far as the random audits... My questions is for how many times
are you talking about? Like 20 years worth, or 3 years... Because I
was audited 2 years in a row. However I don't see the problem with
being audited.. all my ducks are in a row.. and my papers are all in
order.. so bugger them.

SpiderHam77


Henry November 9th 05 01:11 AM

Discrimination against CP Dads in Canada by the CRA
 
wrote in
oups.com:

Since I have been seperated and divorced, I have had my tax return
audited 60% of the times I have filed. Each time they ask for proof
that my son lives with me, plus other personal information. The Canada
Revenue Agency insists that the checks are random, but the math
doesn't work for me. If they randomly check less than 1% of returns,
then checking mine 60% of the time is not a statistical anomoly, it
clearlly indicates specific targetting.

I suspect that the computer checks divorced, male, child deduction -
this must be wrong.

I am looking for any other custodial fathers in Canada that have
experienced similar discrimination by the Canadian Revenue Agency.
Please email me.

Thanks,
Dave Flewitt






This does not surprise me. CRA has the most brutal rules against fathers
I have ever seen. For example, even though I have joint custody, since I
am obliged to pay the ex support, I cannot claim children as
dependents... but my ex can! Also, there are all kinds of nice rules
for deducting legal fees if they are going after money... but I cannot
deduct fees for acces, custody or trying to get my support lowered.

It never ends...


H.

HoyaGuy February 16th 11 03:56 PM

It is time fathers get together and try and fight the CRA and their brutal laws. I am going to my MLA as a starting point but if anyone knows some support groups for fathers they can pass them along. The two rules which are especially tough on me are not being able to claim the child support I pay to my ex on my taxes (for children born after 1995), and the fact that I can't claim my children as dependents on my taxes, eventhough I have them 50% of the time. If anyone knows the exact wording of these rules, the name/code of these rules, and when they were created, please let me know!

Thanks for your help. Let's get these laws changed for struggling fathers everywhere.

Hoya Guy

Quote:

Originally Posted by Henry (Post 321565)
wrote in
oups.com:

Since I have been seperated and divorced, I have had my tax return
audited 60% of the times I have filed. Each time they ask for proof
that my son lives with me, plus other personal information. The Canada
Revenue Agency insists that the checks are random, but the math
doesn't work for me. If they randomly check less than 1% of returns,
then checking mine 60% of the time is not a statistical anomoly, it
clearlly indicates specific targetting.

I suspect that the computer checks divorced, male, child deduction -
this must be wrong.

I am looking for any other custodial fathers in Canada that have
experienced similar discrimination by the Canadian Revenue Agency.
Please email me.

Thanks,
Dave Flewitt






This does not surprise me. CRA has the most brutal rules against fathers
I have ever seen. For example, even though I have joint custody, since I
am obliged to pay the ex support, I cannot claim children as
dependents... but my ex can! Also, there are all kinds of nice rules
for deducting legal fees if they are going after money... but I cannot
deduct fees for acces, custody or trying to get my support lowered.

It never ends...


H.



All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:24 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
ParentingBanter.com