If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Drop in antibodies after 6 months?
This link was in my BabyCenter email for this week.
http://tinyurl.com/35y5w I was very surprised to read this in it, under the section on preventing ear infections: "Practitioners such as Ruben believe that mothers transfer certain immune-building antibodies to their babies through breast milk. However, those antibodies seem to decrease after the six-month mark." I was glad to see the plug for bf'ing but I have never heard of the antibodies in breastmilk decreasing after 6 months. I thought one of the prime reasons for extended bf'ing is the antibodies. Anyone know what they're talking about, or if it isn't true? -- Cheryl S. Mom to Julie, 3 (today!), and Jaden, 6 months Quiet down, cobwebs. Dust go to sleep. I'm rocking my baby and babies don't keep. |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Drop in antibodies after 6 months?
"Cheryl S." wrote in message
This link was in my BabyCenter email for this week. http://tinyurl.com/35y5w I was very surprised to read this in it, under the section on preventing ear infections: "Practitioners such as Ruben believe that mothers transfer certain immune-building antibodies to their babies through breast milk. However, those antibodies seem to decrease after the six-month mark." I was glad to see the plug for bf'ing but I have never heard of the antibodies in breastmilk decreasing after 6 months. I thought one of the prime reasons for extended bf'ing is the antibodies. Anyone know what they're talking about, or if it isn't true? We talked about this briefly at my LLL meeting last night. According to what the Leader said, the drop in antibodies corresponds with the introduction of other substances into the baby's digestive system (i.e. solid foods). I believe the info came from the Womanly Art book (of which I know you are a *huge* fan! j/k ;-). Speaking of the Womanly Art book, I learned something else new when reading the section on introduction of solids. It said that if you start solids after the 6 month mark, you don't have to start with purees, but that babies are usually ready for more "biting" types of activities like mushed up banana (or even banana chunks). That was news to me. I thought purees were the gospel for first foods! -- Em mama to L-baby, 6 months old this Sunday |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Drop in antibodies after 6 months?
"Cheryl S." wrote in message
I was very surprised to read this in it, under the section on preventing ear infections: "Practitioners such as Ruben believe that mothers transfer certain immune-building antibodies to their babies through breast milk. However, those antibodies seem to decrease after the six-month mark." snip I just checked the Womanly Art again and it says, "when solid foods replace human milk in a baby's diet, it decreases the protective antibodies the baby receives." It states this as one of the reasons to wait to introduce solids after 6 months (one of the others is allergies). So, I'm thinking that "seem to decrease" is someone who is just not looking at the context in which the decrease occurs. (Or, who wants to make breastfeeding seem un or less important. I'm suspicious of the motives for that quote!!) -- Em mama to L-baby, 6 months old this Sunday! |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Drop in antibodies after 6 months?
"Cheryl S."
I was very surprised to read this in it, under the section on preventing ear infections: "Practitioners such as Ruben believe that mothers transfer certain immune-building antibodies to their babies through breast milk. However, those antibodies seem to decrease after the six-month mark." Anecdotally - Hunter got his first ear infection right at 6 months. No solids yet. Probably coincidence ;-) Em wrote: It said that if you start solids after the 6 month mark, you don't have to start with purees, but that babies are usually ready for more "biting" types of activities like mushed up banana (or even banana chunks). That was news to me. I thought purees were the gospel for first foods! That was definitely true for Hunter (started at 10mos). Luke had the jarred food at the sitter and finger food (cut/mashed/clumpy) at home (started at 6mos). Neither of mine gagged though and I think that is individual :-) -- Nikki Mama to Hunter (4) and Luke (2) |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Drop in antibodies after 6 months?
"Cheryl S." wrote in message
... and I snipped: Cheryl S. Mom to Julie, 3 (today!), and Jaden, 6 months Happy Birthday to Julie!!! -Patty, mom to Corinne (6y!) and Nathan (3.5y) and stepmom to Victoria (13.5y) |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Drop in antibodies after 6 months?
"Em" wrote in message newsDD6c.40704$1p.588899@attbi_s54... "Cheryl S." wrote in message I was very surprised to read this in it, under the section on preventing ear infections: "Practitioners such as Ruben believe that mothers transfer certain immune-building antibodies to their babies through breast milk. However, those antibodies seem to decrease after the six-month mark." snip I just checked the Womanly Art again and it says, "when solid foods replace human milk in a baby's diet, it decreases the protective antibodies the baby receives." It states this as one of the reasons to wait to introduce solids after 6 months (one of the others is allergies). Well, if you're replacing human milk with solids, of course the baby will receive less protective antibodies. After all, the solids don't have antibodies. It doesn't say that the milk itself has less antibodies. I'm eagerly watching this thread for the answer. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Drop in antibodies after 6 months?
"toypup" wrote in message
"Em" wrote in message "Cheryl S." wrote in message I was very surprised to read this in it, under the section on preventing ear infections: "Practitioners such as Ruben believe that mothers transfer certain immune-building antibodies to their babies through breast milk. However, those antibodies seem to decrease after the six-month mark." snip I just checked the Womanly Art again and it says, "when solid foods replace human milk in a baby's diet, it decreases the protective antibodies the baby receives." It states this as one of the reasons to wait to introduce solids after 6 months (one of the others is allergies). Well, if you're replacing human milk with solids, of course the baby will receive less protective antibodies. After all, the solids don't have antibodies. It doesn't say that the milk itself has less antibodies. I'm eagerly watching this thread for the answer. I know, that's why I said that I think that the person quoted is basing his info on a misinterpretation of what actually happens! That's my theory, but I could be totally off-base. The quote in the OP's post doesn't say whether they tested the milk itself, or whether it is just that babies start having less antibodies at the 6 months mark. Call me skeptical, but I just suspect that the quote is not based on fact! -- Em mama to L-baby, almost 6 months old! |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Drop in antibodies after 6 months?
OK. I actually botheaedr to read the other responses this time first!
:-) I have two things to say. This first is based on the other responses. That is that the protective effects of the antibodies appear to decrease because of the presence of solid foods in the baby's digestive system, probably intefering with absorbtion. The second is studies I have read which directly contradict this. The basic result is that the concentration of immunoglobulins in second year milk is much higher than first year milk. This says that that the immune effects of breastmilk continue well into the second year. That said, then regardless of what Rubin actually meant, I think his statement was irresponsible. It leaves the (incorrect) impression that breastfeeding is less important after 6 months. IM(NS)HO, just the opposite is true. Breastfeeding is more important because it counters some of the stresses inherent is introducing foreign foods. Grrrr (him, not you), Larry Cheryl S. writes: : This link was in my BabyCenter email for this week. : http://tinyurl.com/35y5w : I was very surprised to read this in it, under the section on preventing : ear infections: "Practitioners such as Ruben believe that mothers : transfer certain immune-building antibodies to their babies through : breast milk. However, those antibodies seem to decrease after the : six-month mark." : I was glad to see the plug for bf'ing but I have never heard of the : antibodies in breastmilk decreasing after 6 months. I thought one of : the prime reasons for extended bf'ing is the antibodies. Anyone know : what they're talking about, or if it isn't true? : -- : Cheryl S. : Mom to Julie, 3 (today!), and Jaden, 6 months : Quiet down, cobwebs. Dust go to sleep. : I'm rocking my baby and babies don't keep. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Drop in antibodies after 6 months?
|
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Drop in antibodies after 6 months?
"Cheryl S." wrote in message ... This link was in my BabyCenter email for this week. http://tinyurl.com/35y5w I was very surprised to read this in it, under the section on preventing ear infections: "Practitioners such as Ruben believe that mothers transfer certain immune-building antibodies to their babies through breast milk. However, those antibodies seem to decrease after the six-month mark." I was glad to see the plug for bf'ing but I have never heard of the antibodies in breastmilk decreasing after 6 months. I thought one of the prime reasons for extended bf'ing is the antibodies. Anyone know what they're talking about, or if it isn't true? -- Cheryl S. Mom to Julie, 3 (today!), and Jaden, 6 months Quiet down, cobwebs. Dust go to sleep. I'm rocking my baby and babies don't keep. This is totally just a theory but the antibodies in breastmilk are antibodies that the mother produces to bugs she is exposed to. Perhaps at six months when baby starts to get solids, move around and be held by more people he begins to be exposed to bugs that Mum isn't. So he's getting bugs that Mum hasn't had a chance to make antibodies to. So it wouldn't so much be less anti-bodies but less appropriate anti-bodies. Obviously if the baby was in daycare earlier with my theory the same would apply earlier. What do you think? Judy |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
He's six months old today! | [email protected] | Breastfeeding | 1 | February 11th 04 02:18 PM |
Blocked tear duct at 5 months | Laurie | General | 9 | September 15th 03 06:19 PM |
bf - ammo pro bf past 6 months | FayeTarzwell | Breastfeeding | 27 | August 30th 03 05:24 PM |
Solids; 4 months vs 6 months? | Laurie | Breastfeeding | 5 | August 12th 03 07:35 PM |
Solids; 4 months vs 6? | Laurie | General | 9 | August 12th 03 07:02 PM |