If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
Ability grouping
This is at the elementary level-at high school, ability grouping is alive
and well, with multiple levels of the same class in anything required by the state. Oops, I forgot to say that in my answer about Seattle schools I was talking about elementary school only. I think there are different math tracks in middle school, but it's whole classes, not ability groups. And of course in high school there is the chance to take AP courses or go to the IB school, but again, no individual ability grouping, all at class-level. --Helen |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
Ability grouping
"Nevermind" wrote in message om... I know this will be a very unscientific survey, but I'm curious about how common Erika's school's grouping system (see below) is these days. Our school doesn't officially do ability grouping -- there is *no* expectation that the work the kids're doing in reading or math will be pegged to their individual ability at all, only to their age. It's one-size-fits-all unless the teacher wants to differentiate on her own. How about your kids' elementary schools? I had understood that ability grouping had become rare in U.S. elementary schools, but if I'm wrong about that, then our school district's system is much more vulnerable to criticism and parental agitation for change. At our elementary schools there was grouping in math and reading in first grade, not so much in second or third (more individualized work). At the end of third they take math tests to determine if they learned all of third grade math. If they ace (100%) that they take the end of fourth grade math test, if they pass that they take a few work pages home for the summer, and in fourth grade start attending fifth grade math. This progresses, and in sixth grade they have a special teacher come in and teach 7th grade math. In junior high all math is tracked, and those who were advanced in elementary (as well as a few that caught up since then) take Algebra in 8th grade, and end up in honors Geometry freshman year in high school. I know of one child who skipped two math levels, and would ride her bike between junior high and high school to take Geometry her 8th grade year. Junior high math levels also determined if you took Biology (which counts as a science toward graduation requirements) or Life Sciences (which doesn't, I'm not sure why) as a Freshman in high school. Honors courses in English don't start 'til sophomore year. Those who took two years of a language (Spanish or French) in junior high start in the second year in high school. (French II for instance) Reading and other subjects tend to be pulled back together come third grade. They are then all reading the same book, and tested on comprehension, so it is a given by third grade you could read third grade books. (I believe one book was "Little House on the Prairie". This year in fourth grade they are reading "Island of the Blue Dolphin".) I have had experience that when one of my kids was acing the preliminary spelling tests (the one having never seen the words before) she was excused from spelling for the rest of the week, and sent to write a play with another student who also wasn't needing spelling practice. So it's possible that in other subjects if the child is advanced for the class they are excused to do other interesting work. The GATE program for this district is administered as classes after school, all consolidated at one elementary school. My kids do (and did) have the GATE eligibility box checked on their report cards, but since it cuts into their other after school activities, and is another place to drive to, I didn't look into it. I've heard parents who love the GATE classes and those who aren't impressed. I haven't heard any kid willing to give up soccer for it. |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
Ability grouping
|
#14
|
|||
|
|||
Ability grouping
|
#16
|
|||
|
|||
Ability grouping
In article , Nevermind says...
I know this will be a very unscientific survey, but I'm curious about how common Erika's school's grouping system (see below) is these days. Our school doesn't officially do ability grouping -- there is *no* expectation that the work the kids're doing in reading or math will be pegged to their individual ability at all, only to their age. It's one-size-fits-all unless the teacher wants to differentiate on her own. How about your kids' elementary schools? I had understood that ability grouping had become rare in U.S. elementary schools, but if I'm wrong about that, then our school district's system is much more vulnerable to criticism and parental agitation for change. My son's elementary schools in New York state had ability grouping in reading for most grades. Math ability grouping starts in 6th grade. There is no tracking - efforts are made to have a distribution of abilities in each classroom. Banty |
#17
|
|||
|
|||
Ability grouping
"Cathy Kearns" wrote in message om...
"Nevermind" wrote in message om... I know this will be a very unscientific survey, but I'm curious about how common Erika's school's grouping system (see below) is these days. Our school doesn't officially do ability grouping -- there is *no* expectation that the work the kids're doing in reading or math will be pegged to their individual ability at all, only to their age. It's one-size-fits-all unless the teacher wants to differentiate on her own. How about your kids' elementary schools? I had understood that ability grouping had become rare in U.S. elementary schools, but if I'm wrong about that, then our school district's system is much more vulnerable to criticism and parental agitation for change. At our elementary schools there was grouping in math and reading in first grade, not so much in second or third (more individualized work). At the end of third they take math tests to determine if they learned all of third grade math. If they ace (100%) that they take the end of fourth grade math test, if they pass that they take a few work pages home for the summer, and in fourth grade start attending fifth grade math. This progresses, and in sixth grade they have a special teacher come in and teach 7th grade math. In junior high all math is tracked, and those who were advanced in elementary (as well as a few that caught up since then) take Algebra in 8th grade, and end up in honors Geometry freshman year in high school. I know of one child who skipped two math levels, and would ride her bike between junior high and high school to take Geometry her 8th grade year. This sounds similar to my own elementary school (started kindergarden in '74). But we had two groups in kindergarden - one was expected to learn to read (or already did), and the other wasn't. But, I don't remember math being tracked nearly that much until 7th and 8th grade, where they taught some kids algebra and not others. Junior high math levels also determined if you took Biology (which counts as a science toward graduation requirements) or Life Sciences (which doesn't, I'm not sure why) as a Freshman in high school. Honors courses in English don't start 'til sophomore year. Those who took two years of a language (Spanish or French) in junior high start in the second year in high school. (French II for instance) This corresponds with my own experience, though we had Accelerated English starting in freshman year. Reading and other subjects tend to be pulled back together come third grade. They are then all reading the same book, and tested on comprehension, so it is a given by third grade you could read third grade books. (I believe one book was "Little House on the Prairie". This year in fourth grade they are reading "Island of the Blue Dolphin".) Again, this sounds similar, though I don't exactly remember. We didn't have any separate gifted programs, except for a math program outside of school. I only know one kid who was in it, one of my sister's friends, and he was waay ahead of everyone else. His friends would ask him for help with homework, and he wouldn't remember how to do it in the current method, only in the more advanced methods! (I know the poll is about current stuff, but my ds is only 2...I did think that it was interesting that this was so similar to my own experience, however.) Irene |
#18
|
|||
|
|||
Ability grouping
That's interesting, since my nephew in Fairfield, CT public schools is
profoundly gifted, and the district is paying for a teacher to come and work with him on advanced math. It's a pull out program. They still haven't quite solved the English/Language Arts piece, since it involves driving him over to the high school. He's had a great experience, and they have accomodated him in ways I would not have expected. Here in our urban district in Oakland there is no official ability grouping but in Middle school there is a fairly obvious one... Kids can take Algebra in 7th grade, but only if they are given permission and there appear to be two tracks for "Core" social science/language arts In the k-5 schools, there are certainly lit circles where the teachers pick the students and the book. It's hard for strong boy readers like my kid, since he ends up in circles with mostly girls. We aren't allowed to ability group anymore within a school. A friend of our's, living in Connecticut, has a child who has quite a talent for math (he's been doing Algebra at home with his mother) and he's bored with his classroom math. His parents requested from the teacher and the principal to accelerate his math program. They were flatly refused, being told that it's mandated by the state that every child receive an identical education until grade six, unless they are specifically categorized as learning disabled. The upshot was, they asked me for some homeschooling math resources, then pulled him out of the public school and put him in private school. To their surprise, they found several of the boy's friends who had disappeared from the school that year. Michelle Flutist |
#19
|
|||
|
|||
Ability grouping
I haven't seen ability grouping in public schools recently. Years ago, when
I was a student in Pocatello, Idaho, the school system began "tracking" or ability grouping in 7th grade, and continued through high school. In my opinion, it worked very well. For my kids, we "ability group" just fine, because we homeschool. So my 7 year old that reads at a 6th grade level doesn't get bored, and my 5 year old that does math at 2nd grade level isn't bored, and my 14 year old takes half 10th grade subjects, half 9th grade, while my 17 year old is finishing her high school requirements at the local community college by taking freshman college courses. Where we see deficiencies, we work on those individually. The only hard part is when people ask my kids what grade they are in -- it's hard for them to characterize "Donna Metler" wrote in message .. . "Nevermind" wrote in message om... I know this will be a very unscientific survey, but I'm curious about how common Erika's school's grouping system (see below) is these days. Our school doesn't officially do ability grouping -- there is *no* expectation that the work the kids're doing in reading or math will be pegged to their individual ability at all, only to their age. It's one-size-fits-all unless the teacher wants to differentiate on her own. How about your kids' elementary schools? I had understood that ability grouping had become rare in U.S. elementary schools, but if I'm wrong about that, then our school district's system is much more vulnerable to criticism and parental agitation for change. We aren't allowed to ability group anymore within a school. However, within the district there are several optional schools which only take the high performing students, and one (the one I teach at), which takes only the lowest performing students, so I guess you could say that the district ability groups by school, if the parents choose to take advantage of it. This is at the elementary level-at high school, ability grouping is alive and well, with multiple levels of the same class in anything required by the state. A class which might be one semester or one year for high ability students will be cut into two parts for lower ability students, and go at a much slower pace, but with the same content. Nevermind wrote: Wow -- is ability grouping common in the UK? If I understand correctly, it has been all but wiped out of public schools in the U.S. It sounds like wonderful common sense to me. It sure isn't wiped out in the public schools here. In my sons' school they ability group for math and reading in every grade past kindergarten (except it seems that they don't in the center based GT program, which I suppose makes sense). They have as many groups as they have teachers for that grade. So, this year there are something like six first grade teachers, so they have seven reading groups (each teacher has one, plus there's a reading specialist) and six math groups. The groups are relatively fluid, so children who need to move up or down accordingly. Seems to work like a charm. Best wishes, Ericka |
#20
|
|||
|
|||
Ability grouping
In article ,
Nevermind wrote: I know this will be a very unscientific survey, but I'm curious about how common Erika's school's grouping system (see below) is these days. Our school doesn't officially do ability grouping -- there is *no* expectation that the work the kids're doing in reading or math will be pegged to their individual ability at all, only to their age. It's one-size-fits-all unless the teacher wants to differentiate on her own. How about your kids' elementary schools? My kids' (ex) public elementary did quite a bit of ability grouping for reading (pulled in all sorts of extra people to take groups, a reading specialist and some others) and a little but not so much for math. (In Vermont, fwiw) --Robyn |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Bright 2nd grader & school truancy / part-time home-school? | Vicki | General | 215 | November 1st 03 09:07 PM |