If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#151
|
|||
|
|||
I hate homework!
On Apr 8, 9:06�am, "Donna Metler" wrote:
Frankly, I'd be very suspicious of a class which meets daily that COULD assign homework a week at a time, simply because if you have it ready that far in advance, you're not adjusting to what the students need. A week in advance is far??? My son has a teacher who's giving many of the same assignments she handed out four years ago! I'm pretty sure she just has a batch of photocopy masters filed by week. --Helen |
#152
|
|||
|
|||
I hate homework!
toto wrote:
On 8 Apr 2008 09:53:54 -0700, Banty wrote: The stuff about mainstreamed students (thought there would be persons present or assitants assigned - even a class of non-IEP students have teacher assistants present) has led you to rather inconsistent complaints. Which I take as a sign of, although it may be a stressor, isn't the fundamental problem. They do? Many schools have very few aides. It is almost impossible to get an aide for individual students here. Often classroom aides are shared between 2 to 4 classrooms here. Teacher aides are very uncommon here beyond kindergarten or special ed. classes. Best wishes, Ericka |
#153
|
|||
|
|||
I hate homework!
In article , toto says...
On 8 Apr 2008 09:53:54 -0700, Banty wrote: The stuff about mainstreamed students (thought there would be persons present or assitants assigned - even a class of non-IEP students have teacher assistants present) has led you to rather inconsistent complaints. Which I take as a sign of, although it may be a stressor, isn't the fundamental problem. They do? Many schools have very few aides. It is almost impossible to get an aide for individual students here. Often classroom aides are shared between 2 to 4 classrooms here. I'm not saying they're sufficient, but they were not mentioned *at all* in Donna's account. Banty |
#154
|
|||
|
|||
I hate homework!
|
#155
|
|||
|
|||
I hate homework!
In article , Banty
wrote: They're expected not only to know the tables; they're =A0to be able to beat the clock in *speed drills*. Which only much practice could get. Do we really disagree? Even if the test measures speed as well as accuracy, some students will need more practice than others to meet the standard, and once a child does meet the standard, he should not have to practice that task further. There are better things for him to work on. The standard is such that only a lot of drill gets success. So only a few students would meet that standard. It would have very little effect on the problem as a whole. Of course the question is: why is there such emphasis on speed and drilling when you can buy a cheap, accurate calculator anywhere these days? What exactly is the purpose of all this drill? I don't disagree with the thorough teaching of basic maths, but the overemphasis on drill, in this day and age, seems a bit weird. It reminds me of my Mum's Catholic education in the 1950s. Mum can tot up a column of figures faster than anyone I know, but while it was still a marketable skill back then, it isn't now. -- Chookie -- Sydney, Australia (Replace "foulspambegone" with "optushome" to reply) http://chookiesbackyard.blogspot.com/ |
#156
|
|||
|
|||
I hate homework!
In article ,
"Donna Metler" wrote: One question. Does your school have any stated policy about homework limits (5 or 10 minutes per grade level, plus 20-30 minutes of reading is pretty common). If it does, ask the teacher how long the assignment should take a 7-8 yr old to do. It may be that your child works slower or faster than the teacher expects, and usually it's that the child works slower, but so do ALL children of the child's age. There's no stated policy AFAIK, but the homework is set for the entire grade at once -- the teachers take it in turns to write the sheet. As I mentioned, the homework does vary for ability groups. It may require addressing the problem at a higher level if you have a teacher who honestly believes writing 20 sentences doesn't take very long (and for an adult, it doesn't). DS2's teacher is actually the one in charge of the Stage. What I will be asking her is for any tips she has for the child to form sentences. I agree with Banty that setting time limits only works if the teacher is the one who does it and if it's understood that tasks are for practice, not for completion. No child freaks out about stopping piano practice after 30 minutes because he hasn't played to the end of the page, book, or whatever, because music practice is time limited, not task limited (although part of what you try to teach a child in private study is how to use that time to accomplish tasks). But a worksheet, or assignment to write 20 sentence is task limited inherently. Interesting -- DS1's music homework IS task-based! Play the left-hand part of the new piece. Play each hand of a known piece in turn, then try it hands-together. Is this unusual at age 7? A better assignment would be "Look at the vocabulary words for the week. Read them and define them mentally. Make up sentences for those you're having trouble remembering, and write down at least 5 of them-task should take no more than 10 minutes". I'd like that -- it would mean no HW at all! Or "Look at the math problems on page 102. Do as many as you can complete in 5 minutes, including problems 1, 7, 12, 12, and 20." The reverse side of the HW sheet has maybe 10 problems (the front is literacy work). DS1 does the sheet at after-school care, as a rule. It's the easy part, and the kind of work you can do in a distracting environment -- filling in blanks, drawing lines to indicate relationship, that sort of thing. For both vocabulary and math, often "bellringers", where the students are asked one or two quick questions which came from the homework, is a better choice to see who is mastering the material than grading homework anyway. I think another Aussie merntioned that HW here is marked, but doesn't go towards the final marks for the year. We have a competency-based system and reports are written based on assessment tasks done at school. There is a spot on the report where they tell you that HW is always/usually/rarely done, but that's all. -- Chookie -- Sydney, Australia (Replace "foulspambegone" with "optushome" to reply) http://chookiesbackyard.blogspot.com/ |
#158
|
|||
|
|||
I hate homework!
In article ,
(Beth Kevles) wrote: I know it sounds odd, but YES, try doing the hardest work first when your student is fresh. This has two positive effects: you get the hard stuff out of the way, and you do it while you're best able to concentrate. So you tell your student, "We're going to do this word first, because that's the toughest one. I'll help you with it if you need my help. And when you've done it, everything else will be easier! So the more you work, the easier it will get!" It's not that the WORDS are tough. It's that INVENTING SENTENCES is tough. NO sentence is easier than another! -- Chookie -- Sydney, Australia (Replace "foulspambegone" with "optushome" to reply) http://chookiesbackyard.blogspot.com/ |
#159
|
|||
|
|||
I hate homework!
Donna Metler wrote:
... I'm not saying it's a good thing-not unless you DO shorten the school day! But I am saying that kids doing work at school isn't nearly as efficient as Jeff would like to believe, It depends on the program. There are some programs where college students tutor students in an after school program. There are others that a just play time for the students. Of course, if the parents don't read or write English, the kids are out of luck at home, other than, if they're lucky, they have a place to work. and the illusion of the teacher being able to help often is not the case for the average child, because the teacher is so occupied with the children who need her more. Not all teachers are male. Again, it depends on the school and the teachers. There are ways for teachers to get more one on one time with students, like spending time with students during individual assignments when going around the room, and having kids keep journals and responding to the kids in the journals. In addition, they can give kids different homework. Finally, homework can be written in such a way that kids with different abilities will be to answer the questions accordingly. It's kind of like having a 6 yr old and a toilet training 2 yr old who is into everything. The 6 yr old simply is NOT getting 50% of the time you can spend with the child. And if you've got a child who can't focus in a chaotic situation, even if the school doesn't assign homework for the sake of homework, and only sends home unfinished assignments, the load can get ridiculous fast, as the child has almost 6 hours of work they were unable to complete in school to finish. Add the 10 minutes per grade per night (and realize that most teachers seem very BAD at time estimates, forgetting that it takes a 6 yr old a LOT longer to write than an adult!) and you quickly have hours of homework every night-with most of it stuff that can't easily be assigned a week at a time because it's coming from that day's lessons. A teacher should know what (s)he will have covered a week in advance. Obviously, things come up (like lunch and other illnesses), snow days, assemblies and other unplanned events, but there should be no problem planning homework a week ahead. Frankly, I'd be very suspicious of a class which meets daily that COULD assign homework a week at a time, simply because if you have it ready that far in advance, you're not adjusting to what the students need. While this is a valid point, it is possible to know what vocabulary words will be covered in history or science class and what the spelling words will be a week in advance. My feeling is that most schools are NOT an efficient way of learning for most individuals-and that the excessive homework is a combination of that lack of efficiency coupled with an increased workload and expectations. It's unlikely that 2nd graders 20 years ago would have been writing 20 sentences for one assignment even in class, because most 2nd graders had only learned to read and write at all in 1st grade, and were still learning in 2nd. Now they're expected to pretty much have those skills mastered by that point. |
#160
|
|||
|
|||
I hate homework!
In article ehrebeniuk-473335.08301709042008@news, Chookie says...
In article , Banty wrote: They're expected not only to know the tables; they're =A0to be able to beat the clock in *speed drills*. Which only much practice could get. Do we really disagree? Even if the test measures speed as well as accuracy, some students will need more practice than others to meet the standard, and once a child does meet the standard, he should not have to practice that task further. There are better things for him to work on. The standard is such that only a lot of drill gets success. So only a few students would meet that standard. It would have very little effect on the problem as a whole. Of course the question is: why is there such emphasis on speed and drilling when you can buy a cheap, accurate calculator anywhere these days? What exactly is the purpose of all this drill? I don't disagree with the thorough teaching of basic maths, but the overemphasis on drill, in this day and age, seems a bit weird. It reminds me of my Mum's Catholic education in the 1950s. Mum can tot up a column of figures faster than anyone I know, but while it was still a marketable skill back then, it isn't now. The given reason for it I actually have some sympathy for - to have the basic math facts at the fingertips is important to more advanced tasks, like fractions, long division, multiplication of three-digit numbers, estimating quantities. One can't begin to solve certain things unless one can quickly see where a number lies, for example, between 8x6 and 8x7. I have a bit of a problem in that, without the actual value of it in front of a student, the drill seems meaningless. My son always did poorly on the speed drills, and was dinged badly in his grades for it. THey'd be graded on what portion of a math facts sheet was completed correctly in a given length of time. But he's doing fairly well in high school math now. Indeed, where he has a problem is when he speeds though stuff! Banty |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Homework Headache | [email protected] | General | 2 | March 18th 07 07:00 PM |
Homework Headache | [email protected] | General | 0 | March 18th 07 04:40 AM |
first day of kindergarten and homework! | toypup | General | 142 | September 8th 06 09:56 AM |
homework hassels | V | Single Parents | 66 | April 3rd 04 11:54 AM |
Homework Help Request | turtledove | Single Parents | 3 | June 30th 03 11:17 PM |