If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
On Sat, 27 Aug 2005, Carlson LaVonne wrote:
wrote: They need the pain and humiliation of a pants down spanking and corner standing. Respect breeds and teaches respect. If you parent with respect, your children will respect you. If you parent as you suggest above, how could you possibly imagine that you deserve any respect from your children? LaVonne So I take it that you don't respect your parents??? Doan |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
Come on, LaVonne, STOP THE LIES! Here are the quotes from her paper: (Question 6): We then asked does physical punishment act as a moderator of there lations between child outcomes and parenting type? --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Page 10 As you can see from Table 7, at all time periods, children from Authoritative, and to a lesser extent Democratic, homes were competent and well-adjusted (Baumrind, 1971,1991). In a preliminary analysis we asked, Do these competent parents use the least physical punishment? The answer is clearly NO with their preschool children. Ninety percent(9 of 10) of Authoritative couples at T1 had scores at or above the mean on the physical punishment scale, and Authoritative or Democratic parents were not disproportionately classified in the Green zone. Thus, the higher competence and lesser maladjustment of the preschool children of the most effective parents was not due to their being spanked infrequently. Parent types did differ, however, by the likelihood that members would resort to overly severe physical punishment. Thus families classified in the Red zone were disproportionately either Authoritarian-Directive or Rejecting/Neglecting (90% at T1,75% at T2, 83% at T3), and no Authoritative parent at any time period fell into the Redzone, although one Democratic parent did. Furthermore , both absolute and relative spanking frequency of Authoritative couples decreased rapidly after Time 1 with only 40% at or above the mean at T2, compared to 58% of all other parents, and by T3 with only 17% at or above the mean, compared to 42% of all other parents. Thus by early adolescence, when we in common with other specialists believe physical punishment tobe developmentally inappropriate, Authoritative and Democratic parents were significantly less likely than other parents to use physical punishment. Does that sound like she "no longer advocates" Authoritatvie Parenting??? Doan On Sat, 27 Aug 2005, Carlson LaVonne wrote: Kane, What is so interesting about this unpublished study is that it is in totally conflict with all of her earlier research. Dr. Baumrind is taught in child development classes at most colleges/universities. She can be credited with the research on permissive, authoritarian, and authoritative parenting, with authoritative parenting showing the most positive results. Suddenly she came out with this "study" that was never published, and she also suddenly no longer advocates what she previously called "authoritative parenting." Public pressure, publicity, politics, who knows? Her most recent "study" had so many flaws that it would never have been published. LaVonne |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|