If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Trick or Treating Part2
I've read the trick or treat thread with interest. I'm curious about
parental attendance while trick or treating. At what age do most of your folks think is acceptable/appropriate for kids to knock on doors with mom or dad? We live in a HUGE neighborhood where we know most of the people. It's very family oriented and the houses are bult very close to each other (just trying to give a description). DD is going to be 12, the day after Halloween and she is in 7th grade; just started middle school. She hasn't asked to go alone (yet) but I expect her to at any moment :-) We've always had it that her dad took her around with or without a friend or they've traveled in groups with other kids and parents. I'm thinking Dad still needs to be with her another year or two. It's not her that I don't trust....you know? My intellect tells me that there are a bunch of kids out with parents, we've lived in this neighborhood for almost 8 years, she can take a cell phone and yada yada yada. But my gut says, go with dad. I hand out the candy at home and make a cake for her birthday. Thanks in advance. |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Trick or Treating Part2
On Mon, 9 Oct 2006 08:34:21 EDT, "beachpeach"
wrote: I've read the trick or treat thread with interest. I'm curious about parental attendance while trick or treating. At what age do most of your folks think is acceptable/appropriate for kids to knock on doors with mom or dad? By the time our older child was 10 or so, our kids went out in a clump in our neighbourhood with another family or two and *someone's* parent(s) strolling along behind. This was a step beyond just doing it as a nuclear family. When each reached 12 and grade 7 (middle school), one went out with a group chaperoned by a friend's older sister, in the friend's neighbourhood, and the other went with a group of sensible friends and no parents in our neighbourhood. We always drove them to and from the rendezvous/departure house, and had some rules about when they'd be off the streets and when we'd pick them up. As they got older, we also made our house available for the scary-movie-watching and sleepovers that their festivities turned into. For comparison, at the ages they were going out for Hallowe'en without a parent, they were starting to go a few blocks to the library or grocery store after dark with another kid the same age but not alone. Some of their friends were still chauffeured everywhere, and years from being allowed/required to walk. Some of their friends' parents had very gender-based rules, such as "You have to get a boy to walk you home" which seemed odd to us. We didn't have cell phones, but we did talk with our kids about where the pay phones were, and they carried quarters. They didn't carry UNICEF charity boxes except when they were young enough to have a parent with them. Louise |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Trick or Treating Part2
"beachpeach" wrote:
I've read the trick or treat thread with interest. I'm curious about parental attendance while trick or treating. At what age do most of your folks think is acceptable/appropriate for kids to knock on doors with mom or dad? We live in a HUGE neighborhood where we know most of the people. It's very family oriented and the houses are bult very close to each other (just trying to give a description). DD is going to be 12, the day after Halloween and she is in 7th grade; just started middle school. She hasn't asked to go alone (yet) but I expect her to at any moment :-) We've always had it that her dad took her around with or without a friend or they've traveled in groups with other kids and parents. I'm thinking Dad still needs to be with her another year or two. It's not her that I don't trust....you know? My intellect tells me that there are a bunch of kids out with parents, we've lived in this neighborhood for almost 8 years, she can take a cell phone and yada yada yada. But my gut says, go with dad. I hand out the candy at home and make a cake for her birthday. Thanks in advance. I'm thinking of this from a different perspective. He may want to go. His little girl is growing up after all and this is possibly the last time for him to do this. If he does, then let him go with her, or at least wander along behind if she objects. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Trick or Treating Part2
Rosalie B. wrote: "beachpeach" wrote: I've read the trick or treat thread with interest. I'm curious about parental attendance while trick or treating. At what age do most of your folks think is acceptable/appropriate for kids to knock on doors with mom or dad? We live in a HUGE neighborhood where we know most of the people. It's very family oriented and the houses are bult very close to each other (just trying to give a description). DD is going to be 12, the day after Halloween and she is in 7th grade; just started middle school. She hasn't asked to go alone (yet) but I expect her to at any moment :-) We've always had it that her dad took her around with or without a friend or they've traveled in groups with other kids and parents. I'm thinking Dad still needs to be with her another year or two. It's not her that I don't trust....you know? My intellect tells me that there are a bunch of kids out with parents, we've lived in this neighborhood for almost 8 years, she can take a cell phone and yada yada yada. But my gut says, go with dad. I hand out the candy at home and make a cake for her birthday. Thanks in advance. I'm thinking of this from a different perspective. He may want to go. His little girl is growing up after all and this is possibly the last time for him to do this. If he does, then let him go with her, or at least wander along behind if she objects. Oh my gosh; did I ever give the wrong impression! I want him to go. I don't want her to go without him or atleast another adult! It's not her that I don't trust. It's a car that is driving too fast as she's crossing the street, older teens who are out with cartons of eggs or any other icky stuff that happens in life. I want him to go with our daughter and I want to be fair about it. I don't want to be overly protective ( I tend to be- I'm a social worker and my sister is a public defender; that does tend to color our world :-) I would have him trick or treat with her until 12th grade if it were my choice :-) He and I talked about it last night and he said that pretty much stays in teh background. If she objects, we talked about him staying in the background X 2. I'm just not comfortable letting go yet. Thanks for your response...and to the other poster too! |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Trick or Treating Part2
"beachpeach" wrote:
Rosalie B. wrote: I'm thinking of this from a different perspective. He may want to go. His little girl is growing up after all and this is possibly the last time for him to do this. If he does, then let him go with her, or at least wander along behind if she objects. Oh my gosh; did I ever give the wrong impression! I want him to go. I don't want her to go without him or atleast another adult! It's not I realized that you wanted him to go with her. I was basically asking you whether he might ALSO want to go with her. That was what I meant by looking at it from a different perspective. His perspective rather than yours or hers. her that I don't trust. It's a car that is driving too fast as she's crossing the street, older teens who are out with cartons of eggs or any other icky stuff that happens in life. I want him to go with our daughter and I want to be fair about it. I don't want to be overly protective ( I tend to be- I'm a social worker and my sister is a public defender; that does tend to color our world :-) I would have him trick or treat with her until 12th grade if it were my choice :-) He and I talked about it last night and he said that pretty much stays in teh background. If she objects, we talked about him staying in the background X 2. I'm just not comfortable letting go yet. Thanks for your response...and to the other poster too! |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Trick or Treating Part2
In article , Rosalie B. says...
"beachpeach" wrote: Rosalie B. wrote: I'm thinking of this from a different perspective. He may want to go. His little girl is growing up after all and this is possibly the last time for him to do this. If he does, then let him go with her, or at least wander along behind if she objects. Oh my gosh; did I ever give the wrong impression! I want him to go. I don't want her to go without him or atleast another adult! It's not I realized that you wanted him to go with her. I was basically asking you whether he might ALSO want to go with her. That was what I meant by looking at it from a different perspective. His perspective rather than yours or hers. As long as there's someone at home for the trick or treaters? With our little mom-kid family, we always had to figure out a way to get the trick or treating done but still have me there to hold down the house, so to speak. Banty |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Trick or Treating Part2
On Thu, 12 Oct 2006 11:25:46 EDT, Banty
wrote: In article , Rosalie B. says... "beachpeach" wrote: Rosalie B. wrote: I'm thinking of this from a different perspective. He may want to go. His little girl is growing up after all and this is possibly the last time for him to do this. If he does, then let him go with her, or at least wander along behind if she objects. Oh my gosh; did I ever give the wrong impression! I want him to go. I don't want her to go without him or atleast another adult! It's not I realized that you wanted him to go with her. I was basically asking you whether he might ALSO want to go with her. That was what I meant by looking at it from a different perspective. His perspective rather than yours or hers. As long as there's someone at home for the trick or treaters? With our little mom-kid family, we always had to figure out a way to get the trick or treating done but still have me there to hold down the house, so to speak. So what have you done? When one of our neighbours became a single mum, we realized that collaborative solutions were going to be useful, and then we discovered that it was actually more fun to supervise a crowd of kids who liked each other, rather than just ours. We also discovered that, in our comfort levels, the age for staying home alone handing out candy was actually higher than the age for trick-or-treating with peers. Louise |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Trick or Treating Part2
"beachpeach" wrote in message ps.com... I've read the trick or treat thread with interest. I'm curious about parental attendance while trick or treating. At what age do most of your folks think is acceptable/appropriate for kids to knock on doors with mom or dad? FWIW, I have some friends that take wine glasses when they go trick or treating with their kids. When the kids say "trick or treat", the parents hold out their wine glasses. They say they get to really know their neighbors this way, and they enjoy trick-or-treating much more. -- Warm Regards, Claire Petersky http://www.bicyclemeditations.org/ See the books I've set free at: http://bookcrossing.com/referral/Cpetersky |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Trick or Treating Part2
In article , Louise says...
On Thu, 12 Oct 2006 11:25:46 EDT, Banty wrote: In article , Rosalie B. says... "beachpeach" wrote: As long as there's someone at home for the trick or treaters? With our little mom-kid family, we always had to figure out a way to get the trick or treating done but still have me there to hold down the house, so to speak. So what have you done? When one of our neighbours became a single mum, we realized that collaborative solutions were going to be useful, and then we discovered that it was actually more fun to supervise a crowd of kids who liked each other, rather than just ours. We also discovered that, in our comfort levels, the age for staying home alone handing out candy was actually higher than the age for trick-or-treating with peers. Yes - one way was hooking up with neighbors. When my son was little, I'd make the rounds very early with him, leaving a bowl of candy for other earlies (who are only the really young kids with their parents pretty much), then return home for the bulk of the trick or treaters. I'd have to leave work early for that, though, and make it up. By time my son was ten, he'd go around with friends, and in this area I'm comfortable with that. The last couple of years, I let him go with my cell phone, with an agreement to call every 15 minutes (he did). Banty |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Trick or Treating Part2
Claire Petersky wrote:
FWIW, I have some friends that take wine glasses when they go trick or treating with their kids. When the kids say "trick or treat", the parents hold out their wine glasses. They say they get to really know their neighbors this way, and they enjoy trick-or-treating much more. That sounds like fun! I'm not sure I'd have the chutzpah to do it, though. beeswing |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
the hot water bottle trick works | Vicky Bilaniuk | Pregnancy | 0 | September 9th 04 04:02 PM |
Treating the problem | Kane | General | 0 | January 24th 04 07:37 PM |
Treating the problem | Kane | Foster Parents | 0 | January 24th 04 07:37 PM |
Treating the problem | Kane | Solutions | 0 | January 24th 04 07:37 PM |
Treating the problem | wexwimpy | Foster Parents | 0 | January 24th 04 04:51 PM |