If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#21
|
|||
|
|||
discipline
In article ,
"James and Karen Stewart" wrote: Alot of you have said stricter, but how do you get stricter, We feel like all we do is yell, and it is makig us both feel depressed and useless...like we may as well be talking to the wall. When she comes out of her room we are screaming at her "get to your bed NOW !!!" We take her back up, cover her again and shut her door, she is crying and screaming back " I'm scared, I'm really really scared" Then I go back in tell her " If you don't go to bed whatever you are scared of in here is nothing to what you should be scared of ...ME!!!" "GO TO SLEEP !!!!!!!!" the screaming continues...so how to I be more strict without holding her down or gluing her to the bed. ??? Or geting a strait jacket for her so she can't open the door !!....HEHE Thanks for all suggestions KAren It sounds as though your household is in an incredibly negative cycle regarding bedtime, and something rather drastic may need to be done to break the cycle. This is kind of a bizarre suggestion, but you might try attacking it from the other end: try telling them that you are going to set the get-up time, but you are going to let them set their own bedtime: the only rule is that they have to go into their rooms and change into pajamas (or whatever other evening ritual you want) when they go to bed. Then start getting the kids up REALLY EARLY in the morning (like 6 AM or even earlier). Explain that if they start to fall asleep in the living room, you will know that it is bedtime, and they will have to go to bed, because they've gotten too big to carry -- but as long as they are awake and want to be awake, when they go to bed is up to them, at least for the rest of the summer. You will have to pay enough attention to jog them awake whenever they start to drift off -- but do it cheerfully and with some sort of raucaus activity. You might eliminate any TV or videos in the evening. Try to stick with it *without comment on the time they choose to go to bed* for at least three weeks: the first ten days at least for them to believe that they are really choosing their own bedtime, the next for them to figure out when they are tired enough to go to sleep. Since they don't usually nap, you may have to work at keeping them awake during the day -- but do it. The most important thing will be consistency and cheerfulness. The hard part is that YOU will have to get up at 0-dark-thirty every day, and drag them out of bed. However, by putting them in charge of bedtime, they MAY figure out how much sleep they need and how to go to bed at night without the two hours of misery. This is sort of a variant of what I did when my kids were older: I told them that once they could get up on their own, with their own alarm clock, and get dressed and breakfasted and to school on time without me having to wake them or do any nagging, they could set their own bedtime. For us, that worked like a charm. My oldest stayed up ALL NIGHT the first night -- and found out why I usually sent her to bed earlier. Alternatively, you might even say that for the next four weeks, there will be NO bedtime, and they can set their own schedules completely; that wouldn't work well for me, I don't think, but it might break the cycle of what HAS been happening enough to allow a new pattern once school starts. Mostly, I think when a household has fallen into a negitive cycle about anything, some sort of drastic change may be the only way to break the cycle -- and those are the most drastic changes *I* can think of. meh -- Children won't care how much you know until they know how much you care |
#22
|
|||
|
|||
discipline
On Mon, 28 Jul 2003 02:11:29 GMT, dragonlady
wrote: well, yes and no It's OK to tell her there are no monsters: that's just a statement of fact. It doesn't do any good, and DOES belittle her, to insist that she has to stop being afraid: she IS afraid, and that, too, is just a statement of fact. Yours is a good approach, imo. I like to use more imagination in terms of allowing kids to *conquer* the monsters, but that is just different styles and not difference in substance. Both your posts give good advice, imo... And the OP can take what she likes from either of us and leave the things she dislikes out. -- Dorothy There is no sound, no cry in all the world that can be heard unless someone listens .. Outer Limits |
#23
|
|||
|
|||
discipline
Bippy wrote:
----- Original Message ----- From: "toto" Newsgroups: misc.kids Sent: Sunday, July 27, 2003 3:15 PM Subject: discipline | No, that's not discipline. Punishment and discipline are not | synonyms. Actually, they *are* synonyms. ;-) www.m-w.com -------------- Only because of human **** who think that way, in other words, usage by a fraction of the populace has NO relation to Truth! Seriously, when bribes and reward charts don't work, reasoning and pleading have failed, sometimes you just have to find their "sweet spot" and threaten it. For a social child, you might tell them if they come out of their room they'll be grounded. For children who love their TV, they would lose that priviledge. Or it might mean losing sweets or soda for a while, or missing a special event coming up, or a playdate. Consider what they love the most at that particular moment and threaten to yank it if they disobey. Nothing wrong with that. -------------------- You deserve to be dragged to the curb and shot through the head. What you recommend is PRECISELY what causes all the evil on earth!! You're a vicious abusive cowardly little religious bigot. And you're nothing but live human ****. Steve |
#24
|
|||
|
|||
discipline
x-no-archive:yes
blacksalt wrote: I was number 6, and it was always my father's job to get us to bed. We had a ritual, as I recall bathing, brushing and a read story. If I didn't seem ready to go to sleep promptly, he lay in bed with me, in the dark, with my head on his arm, and we **very quietly** talked. Sometimes he sang Swanee River, very quietly, sometimes we talked about a spider on the ceiling (who was wandering around because he dropped his lolly pop), or he told stories. Sometimes we did slow, even breathing together, and relaxed one limb at a time. When I was definitely sleepy, he'd put on the nightlight (I was terribly afraid of monsters), and tip I do not remember being afraid of monsters and AFAIK none of my kids were either. At least I didn't believe in monsters and they never had any trouble sleeping or ever told me they were afraid of monsters. I don't know if this is inherited or not? My mom did not let us see any scarey movies and my kids didn't see much TV either because in those days (40 years ago) it wasn't common to have more than one set, there was no cable to speak of, no video tapes - altogether a simpler time. My sister and I were 2.5 years apart, and we were read the same books. There was no - different books for different ages stuff. My two oldest are 2 years apart, and they also had the same books read to them. Of course some of this may be because we shared a bedroom and my oldest two shared a bedroom until they were 2nd and 4th grades. toe out. I think it was like a kind of child hypnosis...and took a good part of his time, given all the years he did it for all of us. The summer I had my niece and nephew, it was the same thing, only I never had to lay in bed with them and talk. They did take a hour of my nights with the ritual, however. When they seemed alittle restless, I'd have them sleep on the porch (the 'thrill of camping') in their bags and I'd lay on the floor this side of the door and tell them a last story while they looked at the stars. Personally, I'd start a ritual, staying with her until she fell asleep if necessary, and then start paring back. But be prepared to give up an hour of your evening. I felt just *cherished* by my father, and that was probably the secret. blacksalt It sounds like that to me too. We were on a train trip and my sister wanted my dad to read her a story. It was about midnight. My dad was working on something, and he said he'd read her a story if she could stay awake until he finished what he was doing. She was asleep almost instantly. I used the same technique with mine when I wanted them to take a nap. If they were still awake after lying quiet and still on their bed for 15 minutes, then they could get up and play quietly in their room until their sister woke up from her nap. And the younger sister often did take a nap. (If she didn't lie quiet, then the time started over) It sounds to me like a couple of things with the OP. First - she has an unrealistic idea of what discipline is and what is effective behavior modification for a child. So what she is doing is not working, and she doesn't know how to change it. Second- the children have gotten into the habit of getting attention by crying and acting out. And your son wants to be with his parents on the couch where interesting stuff is going on. There are several approaches to take. 1) As someone else (meh) suggested, don't have a bedtime, but an enforced getting up time. You might do that anyway even without the idea that they can set their own bedtime. Very good idea. 2) When you want her/them to go to bed, you and your husband take them (one each) up to bed, put them in bed and stay with them for a reasonable amount of time. Leave the lights on if they want. Or a radio or nightlights or whatever seems reasonable. Let them decide whether they want a light and what kind. Or if they want the door open or not. Then go into your bedroom. Tell the children that you will be there if there is an emergency, but otherwise they are not to disturb you. If they come out of their rooms, don't speak to them, just take them back to bed. No screaming or shouting or even talking - just take them back to bed every time they come out of their room. It may take some time since they will not believe that behavior that has been successful will not be successful again if they persist. That way, there isn't any reason for ds to fall asleep on the couch - no one will be there to cuddle with. If you and dh want to watch TV, maybe get a small set for the bedroom, but don't use it at first. And don't let them get into bed with you unless you want to do that. grandma Rosalie |
#25
|
|||
|
|||
discipline
I think that poart of this problem was caused by having them in my bed when
they were babies, it started with the breastfeeding,bringing them into my bed to feed during the night. Then as they grew they just would wake in the middle of the night thinking it was the community bed they would climb in. I and my hubby most times would not wake up when they did this so they would stay all night. I must say that last night was a good night with my DD. What we did yesterday is set down a list of rules, I made them up ...asking for input on what should be her bedtime, she clearly doesn't yet understand time after telling me 7:00.....seeing as right now it isn't even dark at 7 pm, it would be hard for her to go to bed then ( this tends to be a complaint "it isn't dark yet" she tells me that when it is bedtime and no dark, assuming it must be dark for bedtime). Anyhow I made up 3 rules last night, one being that she is to remeber to ask for her snakc if she wants one beofre going up the stairs and that bedtime is at 8:30-9:00 and that by 9:00 she must be in bed, with no complaints of not being tired or being thirsty. I also made up a few other rules, one to do with picking up her toys and cleaning her room when she is asked and respecting mom and dad when we request these things to be done. If she doesn't do what she is asked then she will not be able to go out of the yard to play or not be able to watch her cartoons, or no movie night etc. She seems to understand that she needs to do certain things, she just needs to know the consequences. So last night we did a really fast bath thanks to DH, the kids had decided to put the wet sand all over their legs, so a bath was needed. After bath they got dreses ( with some help for DS) and then they asked for a snack, after snack it was 9;00 and up to bed she went, I took her up and she asked for daddy to come up and say goodnight to, so he did. In the meantime DS had cuddle up on the couch with his horsey and he was nearly asleep when DH came back down from saying night to DD. So all in all, we had from 9:20- 10:30 to ourselves, then we went to bed, having had a nice adult relaxing time, quiet time, and some adult conversation. Karen "Rosalie B." wrote in message ... x-no-archive:yes blacksalt wrote: I was number 6, and it was always my father's job to get us to bed. We had a ritual, as I recall bathing, brushing and a read story. If I didn't seem ready to go to sleep promptly, he lay in bed with me, in the dark, with my head on his arm, and we **very quietly** talked. Sometimes he sang Swanee River, very quietly, sometimes we talked about a spider on the ceiling (who was wandering around because he dropped his lolly pop), or he told stories. Sometimes we did slow, even breathing together, and relaxed one limb at a time. When I was definitely sleepy, he'd put on the nightlight (I was terribly afraid of monsters), and tip I do not remember being afraid of monsters and AFAIK none of my kids were either. At least I didn't believe in monsters and they never had any trouble sleeping or ever told me they were afraid of monsters. I don't know if this is inherited or not? My mom did not let us see any scarey movies and my kids didn't see much TV either because in those days (40 years ago) it wasn't common to have more than one set, there was no cable to speak of, no video tapes - altogether a simpler time. My sister and I were 2.5 years apart, and we were read the same books. There was no - different books for different ages stuff. My two oldest are 2 years apart, and they also had the same books read to them. Of course some of this may be because we shared a bedroom and my oldest two shared a bedroom until they were 2nd and 4th grades. toe out. I think it was like a kind of child hypnosis...and took a good part of his time, given all the years he did it for all of us. The summer I had my niece and nephew, it was the same thing, only I never had to lay in bed with them and talk. They did take a hour of my nights with the ritual, however. When they seemed alittle restless, I'd have them sleep on the porch (the 'thrill of camping') in their bags and I'd lay on the floor this side of the door and tell them a last story while they looked at the stars. Personally, I'd start a ritual, staying with her until she fell asleep if necessary, and then start paring back. But be prepared to give up an hour of your evening. I felt just *cherished* by my father, and that was probably the secret. blacksalt It sounds like that to me too. We were on a train trip and my sister wanted my dad to read her a story. It was about midnight. My dad was working on something, and he said he'd read her a story if she could stay awake until he finished what he was doing. She was asleep almost instantly. I used the same technique with mine when I wanted them to take a nap. If they were still awake after lying quiet and still on their bed for 15 minutes, then they could get up and play quietly in their room until their sister woke up from her nap. And the younger sister often did take a nap. (If she didn't lie quiet, then the time started over) It sounds to me like a couple of things with the OP. First - she has an unrealistic idea of what discipline is and what is effective behavior modification for a child. So what she is doing is not working, and she doesn't know how to change it. Second- the children have gotten into the habit of getting attention by crying and acting out. And your son wants to be with his parents on the couch where interesting stuff is going on. There are several approaches to take. 1) As someone else (meh) suggested, don't have a bedtime, but an enforced getting up time. You might do that anyway even without the idea that they can set their own bedtime. Very good idea. 2) When you want her/them to go to bed, you and your husband take them (one each) up to bed, put them in bed and stay with them for a reasonable amount of time. Leave the lights on if they want. Or a radio or nightlights or whatever seems reasonable. Let them decide whether they want a light and what kind. Or if they want the door open or not. Then go into your bedroom. Tell the children that you will be there if there is an emergency, but otherwise they are not to disturb you. If they come out of their rooms, don't speak to them, just take them back to bed. No screaming or shouting or even talking - just take them back to bed every time they come out of their room. It may take some time since they will not believe that behavior that has been successful will not be successful again if they persist. That way, there isn't any reason for ds to fall asleep on the couch - no one will be there to cuddle with. If you and dh want to watch TV, maybe get a small set for the bedroom, but don't use it at first. And don't let them get into bed with you unless you want to do that. grandma Rosalie |
#26
|
|||
|
|||
discipline
Putting kids to bed early is abuse,...O.K....... If you say so....(What
EVER!!!) Putting kids to bed early is not JUST so we can have sex, we like to have some time alone together to talk about adult stuff, bills, trips, house chores/ yard work, upcoming birthdays for the children , Xmas...... etc. not just so we can have sex, ( and by the way...just so you know...the lack of sex in a marriage is another stress put on top of the kids not listening and behaving as we wish them to...... ) Putting kids to bed early, if they are not truely tired does not do anything for them it only gives the parents alone time, but I am not doing that...my child telling me she is not tired is only an excuse, which she has used many times, and if you cry wolf often enough nobody will believe you.....and this is what she has done, she has sat on my couch half asleep, yawning and then when we say it's bed time she says "but I'm not tired", in a voice that sounds like it just woke up. It is not that she is not tired it is that she kows we are still up and she doesn't want to miss something. I am not forcing her to go to sleep but she can read and she can look at a book quietly in her room if she is truely not tired, I have no problem with that. I am at home with her and my son all day, at 9 pm it is time for me time, a break from them. I am not ashamed that I would like to have some time to myslef and time alone with my husband so we can have sex once in a while..... I don't agree that you should put on a video and tell the kids to watch it so we can go have sex and come back all happy..... I don't think we should leave the door opened either. I don't know if you have kids, but soething tells me you don't and if you do you shouldn't !! "R. Steve Walz" wrote in message ... James and Karen Stewart wrote: Am I the only one who finds it hard to discipline the children ??? Or is the a common problem ? I have a hard time with bed time. I want the kids to go to bed at a certain time 8:30-9:00 would be great. I find myself doing bathtime, and then snack and then trying to get them into bed and having my 6 year old tell me she is not tired...I tell her that she doesn't have to sleep just go to bed and read a book if she wants to. She doesn't want to go to bed alone..she wants my husband or me to stay with her. Mainly the reason for this is she says she is scared in her room alone..... We have a two storey house and I am wondering what I can doto make her less afraid up their alone. She doesn't read scary books or watch a scary show before bed, and I have gone in her closet in the dark to prove to her that there is nothing in there. What can I do to get her to go upstairs and go to bed before 10-10:30 at night. She will be going to school everyday come Sept. so I need to get this problem fixed. Hubby and I haven't had even an hour or down/alone time at night for the last 2 weeks. We are going insane...sometimes you need just a few hours alone a week, but there is just no time for us to be alone together lately. Please don't suggest that we go out for supper and get a sitter...because we do get time alone....just not often. The kids will be going to their grandparents for a few night and we are going away overnight in Aug. but it's just the last two weeks have been a pain and a really trying time for us with the kids. Also my son wants to cuddle on the couch everynight with me and fall asleep with me. Come Sept he will be starting Junior kindergardten and will need to fall asleep earlier in his own bed. I have tried to suggest cuddling in his bed but he wants to cuddle on the couch. Any ideas Thanks Karen ------------------- You want time for sex, but you're couching it in terms inspired by your shame, which stimulates you to anger and resentment, thus angry efforts at "discipline". Instead, interest your children in leaving you alone and watching a tape in the next room while you have sex in the bedroom. If you're not sane enough to leave the door open, and make sex appear normal to your children, then at least tell them that you have to take a half hour or so doing what mommies and daddies have to do together to stay married. Then come out and cuddle with them afterwards and they will feel the relaxed difference in your demeanor and know that you did something very nice together. You see, this whole thing REALLY isn't about "discipline" at all, it's about getting everyone's needs met, and you can ask that of your kids if you're nice to them, and they will help you. But honor their feelings and needs, and they will honor yours gladly! But putting kids to bed early is merely abuse, they simply aren't tired yet anymore than you are. You're simply taking unfair advantage of your size, and that will cost you a LOT later when they're older!! Steve |
#27
|
|||
|
|||
discipline
"toto" wrote in message
... On Mon, 28 Jul 2003 02:11:29 GMT, dragonlady wrote: well, yes and no It's OK to tell her there are no monsters: that's just a statement of fact. It doesn't do any good, and DOES belittle her, to insist that she has to stop being afraid: she IS afraid, and that, too, is just a statement of fact. Yours is a good approach, imo. I like to use more imagination in terms of allowing kids to *conquer* the monsters, but that is just different styles and not difference in substance. Both your posts give good advice, imo... And the OP can take what she likes from either of us and leave the things she dislikes out. just to give the third variation - after trying to convince my older son when he was little that there were no monsters (& failing spectacularly as you'd expect) we gave him an anti-monster charm & i changed my line to *i* don't believe in monsters (while saying it was ok that he does, because we could fix the problem). he didn't believe in monsters very long after that. with my little son i always just said that i don't believe in monsters (didn't bother trying to convince him otherwise.) he was more curious about different ways to get rid of them (he enjoyed hearing that monsters are scared of mummies & that's why we won't get any, because they are all scared of me & i don't believe in them anyway so they can't come in. it doesn't make logical sense but it worked for him. at the end of the day, what he apparently thought might have been a monster outside was in fact some other noise (can't remember what) which occurred at bedtime one night so i could explain what it was & he doesn't worry any more.) to make a long story short, i think where evidence of no monster activity can possibly be presented, it should be, while acknowledging that the child may still believe in them, but his parents will help allay his fear & help him feel powerful. i do think that fear of monsters in children over 5-ish isn't fear of monsters, but fear of something else (or possibly delaying tactics, or possibly both.) kylie |
#28
|
|||
|
|||
discipline
"James and Karen Stewart" wrote in message
.. . I think that poart of this problem was caused by having them in my bed when they were babies, it started with the breastfeeding,bringing them into my bed to feed during the night. Then as they grew they just would wake in the middle of the night thinking it was the community bed they would climb in. I and my hubby most times would not wake up when they did this so they would stay all night. no, that's not it at all :-) my older son was getting in bed with us until it finally petered out at 6. my younger son (who spent much more time in there as a baby) has done it, iirc, only twice since he left my bed at 7 mos. i just assumed that my older son got comfort from it, or it was a comfort habit for him that he got into, & my younger one just never needed it though he does know he's always welcome to get in in the night if he's scared. some kids just like it & others don't bother. I must say that last night was a good night with my DD. that's good!! :-) kylie |
#29
|
|||
|
|||
discipline
On Mon, 28 Jul 2003 09:15:39 -0400, James and Karen Stewart wrote:
Putting kids to bed early is abuse,...O.K....... If you say so....(What EVER!!!) R.S.W. is the resident net.kook. Your choices are either to killfile him, if you don't like net.kooks, or to use him as fodder for never-ending, mindless entertainment, sort of like watching Survivor. ;-) Sometimes he actually says something meaningful, but it tends to be because of the infinite monkeys/infinite typewriters effect... - Rich |
#30
|
|||
|
|||
discipline
Stop screaming and be firm and nonchalant as you can. I think you are doing
what I do too much of and that is talking too much. Talk less, make expectations clear and follow through. Tell her it is time for bed, read her a book, get her snack. When you are done reading the book, and if she is not tired, then give her some more books to look at or get a tape recorder of her own so she can listen to books or music. Giving her a flashlight may even help. I know it did for my daughter. If she comes down again, take her back upstairs without a lot of talking or reprimanding. Keep doing this and be consistent and she will soon learn that you won't budge on this. What bothers me is that she sounds like my 6-year-old in that she is probably really afraid. Can you not just sit with her for a while until she is relaxed enough? On the nights that were really bad with my daughter, I would either let her sleep with me or I would go sleep with her or at least stay until she was calmed down. I don't think it helps at all to belittle her for her fears. I think you need to find the underlying cause of why she doesn't want to go to sleep. Perhaps during the day, when she is calm, talk about her fears, ask what scares her and talk through it. Perhaps she has some ideas of what would help her go to sleep. Putting my daughter in with her older sister has helped a lot, but now she won't go to bed without her sister, but it works for me for all of my girls to go to bed at the same time. Monsters were a big problem with my now 6-year-old and started when she was three. I don't like the monster spray idea because after you say there are no monsters, but then get the monster spray, it is kind of hypocritical. I empowered my daughter and told her to tell the monsters that she is afraid of to go away. I left a light on in her room and I let her look under the bed and in the attic to give her control of her fears. The books that someone has mentioned are the same books I read. I am just really consistent with bedtime and as a result, I don't have many issues surrounding it. I have a lot of problems with *positive disipline* also Karen, so you're not alone. It is very hard to change the way you are used to disiplining, but I think you owe it to yourself and you're kids, if you find a new technique. I have been reading Love and Logic and I can't say enough good things about the book. Maybe you can read it and it will give you some better techniques to use. Good luck. Email me if you want to vent or scream, I can relate very well to how you are feeling. Oh, and killfile Steve. He is an idiot and not to be listened to. -- Sue mom to three girls James and Karen Stewart wrote in message ... Alot of you have said stricter, but how do you get stricter, We feel like all we do is yell, and it is makig us both feel depressed and useless...like we may as well be talking to the wall. When she comes out of her room we are screaming at her "get to your bed NOW !!!" We take her back up, cover her again and shut her door, she is crying and screaming back " I'm scared, I'm really really scared" Then I go back in tell her " If you don't go to bed whatever you are scared of in here is nothing to what you should be scared of ...ME!!!" "GO TO SLEEP !!!!!!!!" the screaming continues...so how to I be more strict without holding her down or gluing her to the bed. ??? Or geting a strait jacket for her so she can't open the door !!....HEHE Thanks for all suggestions KAren "James and Karen Stewart" wrote in message ... Am I the only one who finds it hard to discipline the children ??? Or is the a common problem ? I have a hard time with bed time. I want the kids to go to bed at a certain time 8:30-9:00 would be great. I find myself doing bathtime, and then snack and then trying to get them into bed and having my 6 year old tell me she is not tired...I tell her that she doesn't have to sleep just go to bed and read a book if she wants to. She doesn't want to go to bed alone..she wants my husband or me to stay with her. Mainly the reason for this is she says she is scared in her room alone..... We have a two storey house and I am wondering what I can doto make her less afraid up their alone. She doesn't read scary books or watch a scary show before bed, and I have gone in her closet in the dark to prove to her that there is nothing in there. What can I do to get her to go upstairs and go to bed before 10-10:30 at night. She will be going to school everyday come Sept. so I need to get this problem fixed. Hubby and I haven't had even an hour or down/alone time at night for the last 2 weeks. We are going insane...sometimes you need just a few hours alone a week, but there is just no time for us to be alone together lately. Please don't suggest that we go out for supper and get a sitter...because we do get time alone....just not often. The kids will be going to their grandparents for a few night and we are going away overnight in Aug. but it's just the last two weeks have been a pain and a really trying time for us with the kids. Also my son wants to cuddle on the couch everynight with me and fall asleep with me. Come Sept he will be starting Junior kindergardten and will need to fall asleep earlier in his own bed. I have tried to suggest cuddling in his bed but he wants to cuddle on the couch. Any ideas Thanks Karen |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Embarrassing Students Isn't "Discipline" | billy f | General | 15 | July 16th 03 02:43 PM |