A Parenting & kids forum. ParentingBanter.com

If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Go Back   Home » ParentingBanter.com forum » misc.kids » Pregnancy
Site Map Home Authors List Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read Web Partners

Preparing sibling for birth process?



 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #91  
Old April 19th 08, 05:26 AM posted to misc.kids.pregnancy,misc.kids
[email protected]
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 57
Default Preparing sibling for birth process?

On Apr 14, 5:36 am, Banty wrote:
In article , toypup says...





wrote in message
...


I mean with the advent of air conditioned offices and careers in which
men and women can produce equal results, such as in computers. The
jobs of the past women did not want to do and they still do not want
to do jobs of physical labor. However, if there ever becomes a day
where a person can construct a building or home with a push of a
button, women will jump on that opportunity.


And why not? If a woman can do It as well as or better than a man and she
wants to do it, why not?


This air conditioned office thing is just plain silly. There are female
soldiers, female firefighters, female ironworkers, female atheletes. Never mind
recent examples, we have Clara Barton working in hot battlefields, Jane Goodall
working and living in jungles.

I guess he imagines it's the women shouldn't swe..., um, perspire.

It's the woman-on-pedestal thing. It's the old expectation that she be an
object of admiration for physical looks, while fulfilling a limited set of
roles. That's long been confused with 'respect'.

Banty


No, not at all. Women, even today, make up the minority of the jobs
you describe. Respect is dying and putting your life on the line for
your wife and children. A married woman covered in a burka in
Afghanistan has more respect and value than an unwed single mother in
America. However, from the American's point of view, she is oppressed.

Regards...

  #92  
Old April 19th 08, 05:58 AM posted to misc.kids.pregnancy,misc.kids
[email protected]
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 57
Default Preparing sibling for birth process?

On Apr 14, 8:17 am, cjra wrote:
On Apr 14, 12:05 am, "toypup" wrote:



wrote in message


...


I mean with the advent of air conditioned offices and careers in which
men and women can produce equal results, such as in computers. The
jobs of the past women did not want to do and they still do not want
to do jobs of physical labor. However, if there ever becomes a day
where a person can construct a building or home with a push of a
button, women will jump on that opportunity.


And why not? If a woman can do It as well as or better than a man and she
wants to do it, why not?


We are not living In primitive conditions anymore and so we are not
constrained by them.


but I agree entirely with the rest of
your statement. The point I was making was that the traditional 50s
marriage model was for the woman always to be the one who stayed home.
You may have meant the phrase 'traditional marriage of the 50s' in a
looser sense, in which case we may be talking at cross-purposes.


[...]


I could care less who stays home. However, I also think having
predetermined roles in place can avoid arguments and build and
maintain a healthy relationship. It is also important to note that
each role is equally important to the stability of the family. When my
wife stayed home, she wasn't seen as a maid (even though her friends
told her she was) and I didn't consider myself to be a walking ATM
machine. Both her and my role were equally important.


I do agree that someone should stay home with the child, if possible. I
also agree that both the role of provider and SAHP are equally important.


You know, I used to think this, and still hope that in a few years
when the bills are paid off, I can stay home because I *want* to.
However, after having my child in daycare for some 18 months now, I've
learned the value of it. She's really thriving, and though I am sure I
could teach her a lot, I can't provide 6 other kids of multiple ages
to play with her all day, every day and teach her things of their own,
nor do I have the experience of child-rearing for 25 years, as my
babysitter does, to guide me. DD really loves her daycare, and I
almost feel guilty when we're home alone on weekends because she has
just mom and dad instead of a bunch of kids to play with. Even if we
were to do playgroups, we wouldn't be able to do that 8 hrs/day
everyday.

As a mom - even one who's been around kids and helped rear others kids
all her adult life, I really turn to my babysitter for advice and
suggestions, as she's had so much more, and varied experience.


That is one of the most pathetic and sadist things I ever heard. I
hope you improve.

I personally prefer that I be home rather than DH. It's sort of a selfish
thing, because I want to see my kids grow up. I'm glad I have that choice.
I wonder if men would like the choice to be home sometimes.



Generally speaking, women like to stay home and men like to work
outside the home. It's a proven study.

My DH likes the idea in theory, but realizes he'd have a hard time
doing it in practice.


Probably not for the reasons you think.

Regards...
  #93  
Old April 19th 08, 01:38 PM posted to misc.kids.pregnancy,misc.kids
Banty
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 2,278
Default Preparing sibling for birth process?

In article ,
says...

On Apr 14, 5:36 am, Banty wrote:
In article , toypup says...





wrote in message
...


I mean with the advent of air conditioned offices and careers in which
men and women can produce equal results, such as in computers. The
jobs of the past women did not want to do and they still do not want
to do jobs of physical labor. However, if there ever becomes a day
where a person can construct a building or home with a push of a
button, women will jump on that opportunity.


And why not? If a woman can do It as well as or better than a man and she
wants to do it, why not?


This air conditioned office thing is just plain silly. There are female
soldiers, female firefighters, female ironworkers, female atheletes. Never mind
recent examples, we have Clara Barton working in hot battlefields, Jane Goodall
working and living in jungles.

I guess he imagines it's the women shouldn't swe..., um, perspire.

It's the woman-on-pedestal thing. It's the old expectation that she be an
object of admiration for physical looks, while fulfilling a limited set of
roles. That's long been confused with 'respect'.

Banty


No, not at all. Women, even today, make up the minority of the jobs
you describe. Respect is dying and putting your life on the line for
your wife and children. A married woman covered in a burka in
Afghanistan has more respect and value than an unwed single mother in
America. However, from the American's point of view, she is oppressed.


And you don't even realize you just said this to an unwed single mother in
America huh.

Banty

  #94  
Old April 19th 08, 01:40 PM posted to misc.kids.pregnancy,misc.kids
Banty
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 2,278
Default Preparing sibling for birth process?

In article ,
says...

On Apr 14, 8:17 am, cjra wrote:
On Apr 14, 12:05 am, "toypup" wrote:



wrote in message


...


I mean with the advent of air conditioned offices and careers in which
men and women can produce equal results, such as in computers. The
jobs of the past women did not want to do and they still do not want
to do jobs of physical labor. However, if there ever becomes a day
where a person can construct a building or home with a push of a
button, women will jump on that opportunity.


And why not? If a woman can do It as well as or better than a man and she
wants to do it, why not?


We are not living In primitive conditions anymore and so we are not
constrained by them.


but I agree entirely with the rest of
your statement. The point I was making was that the traditional 50s
marriage model was for the woman always to be the one who stayed home.
You may have meant the phrase 'traditional marriage of the 50s' in a
looser sense, in which case we may be talking at cross-purposes.


[...]


I could care less who stays home. However, I also think having
predetermined roles in place can avoid arguments and build and
maintain a healthy relationship. It is also important to note that
each role is equally important to the stability of the family. When my
wife stayed home, she wasn't seen as a maid (even though her friends
told her she was) and I didn't consider myself to be a walking ATM
machine. Both her and my role were equally important.


I do agree that someone should stay home with the child, if possible. I
also agree that both the role of provider and SAHP are equally important.


You know, I used to think this, and still hope that in a few years
when the bills are paid off, I can stay home because I *want* to.
However, after having my child in daycare for some 18 months now, I've
learned the value of it. She's really thriving, and though I am sure I
could teach her a lot, I can't provide 6 other kids of multiple ages
to play with her all day, every day and teach her things of their own,
nor do I have the experience of child-rearing for 25 years, as my
babysitter does, to guide me. DD really loves her daycare, and I
almost feel guilty when we're home alone on weekends because she has
just mom and dad instead of a bunch of kids to play with. Even if we
were to do playgroups, we wouldn't be able to do that 8 hrs/day
everyday.

As a mom - even one who's been around kids and helped rear others kids
all her adult life, I really turn to my babysitter for advice and
suggestions, as she's had so much more, and varied experience.


That is one of the most pathetic and sadist things I ever heard. I
hope you improve.


How on earth is that "pathetic" or "sad"??

One person seeks advice from another person who is very experienced in the
matter. Has been happening since people were on the planet.

Your mother never discussed anything with a neighbor over coffee?



I personally prefer that I be home rather than DH. It's sort of a selfish
thing, because I want to see my kids grow up. I'm glad I have that choice.
I wonder if men would like the choice to be home sometimes.



Generally speaking, women like to stay home and men like to work
outside the home. It's a proven study.


Good - then you can give us a cite to that study.

Banty

  #95  
Old April 19th 08, 07:39 PM posted to misc.kids.pregnancy,misc.kids
agsf_57
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 79
Default Preparing sibling for birth process?

On Apr 19, 5:38 am, Banty wrote:
In article ,
says...





On Apr 14, 5:36 am, Banty wrote:
In article , toypup says...


wrote in message
...


I mean with the advent of air conditioned offices and careers in which
men and women can produce equal results, such as in computers. The
jobs of the past women did not want to do and they still do not want
to do jobs of physical labor. However, if there ever becomes a day
where a person can construct a building or home with a push of a
button, women will jump on that opportunity.


And why not? If a woman can do It as well as or better than a man and she
wants to do it, why not?


This air conditioned office thing is just plain silly. There are female
soldiers, female firefighters, female ironworkers, female atheletes. Never mind
recent examples, we have Clara Barton working in hot battlefields, Jane Goodall
working and living in jungles.


I guess he imagines it's the women shouldn't swe..., um, perspire.


It's the woman-on-pedestal thing. It's the old expectation that she be an
object of admiration for physical looks, while fulfilling a limited set of
roles. That's long been confused with 'respect'.


Banty


No, not at all. Women, even today, make up the minority of the jobs
you describe. Respect is dying and putting your life on the line for
your wife and children. A married woman covered in a burka in
Afghanistan has more respect and value than an unwed single mother in
America. However, from the American's point of view, she is oppressed.


And you don't even realize you just said this to an unwed single mother in
America huh.

Banty


Then you should have first hand experience of what I am saying. It's
you and your child. No one to help you in life. No one to put their
life on the line for you and your child. You were some guy's temporary
toilet. Your level of respect and value is the same as of that toilet.
You go girl!

Regards...

  #96  
Old April 19th 08, 08:45 PM posted to misc.kids.pregnancy,misc.kids
agsf_57
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 79
Default Preparing sibling for birth process?

On Apr 19, 5:40 am, Banty wrote:
In article ,
says...

SNIP

That is one of the most pathetic and sadist things I ever heard. I
hope you improve.


How on earth is that "pathetic" or "sad"??


That she rather have her child be raised and in company of strangers
than to sit down with the child and help her grow.

One person seeks advice from another person who is very experienced in the
matter. Has been happening since people were on the planet.

Your mother never discussed anything with a neighbor over coffee?


About abandoning her kids to day care and preferring it? No, I don't
think it ever came up.


Generally speaking, women like to stay home and men like to work
outside the home. It's a proven study.


Good - then you can give us a cite to that study.


You must be kidding me.

I'll even be so brave to cite a source in which the feminist attacked:
http://www.brandeis.edu/centers/cfwp/articles/6661.pdf

"New York Times columnist John Tierney looked at the study and a few
weeks ago concluded that women "want their husbands to be providers
who give them financial security and freedom.""

No ****! They needed a study for this???? One just needs to look at
the beauty market to see women enhancing their appearance to attract
rich successful men. (Generally speaking).

Here's another generalization for you: Men prefer their wives to stay
at home and take care of the house and family rather than pursue a
career.

http://www.annistonstar.com/opinion/...-5a13r1753.htm


Banty


Regards...

  #97  
Old April 19th 08, 09:33 PM posted to misc.kids.pregnancy,misc.kids
Banty
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 2,278
Default Preparing sibling for birth process?

In article ,
agsf_57 says...

On Apr 19, 5:38 am, Banty wrote:
In article ,
says...





On Apr 14, 5:36 am, Banty wrote:
In article , toypup says...


wrote in message
...


I mean with the advent of air conditioned offices and careers in which
men and women can produce equal results, such as in computers. The
jobs of the past women did not want to do and they still do not want
to do jobs of physical labor. However, if there ever becomes a day
where a person can construct a building or home with a push of a
button, women will jump on that opportunity.


And why not? If a woman can do It as well as or better than a man and she
wants to do it, why not?


This air conditioned office thing is just plain silly. There are female
soldiers, female firefighters, female ironworkers, female atheletes. Never

mind
recent examples, we have Clara Barton working in hot battlefields, Jane

Goodall
working and living in jungles.


I guess he imagines it's the women shouldn't swe..., um, perspire.


It's the woman-on-pedestal thing. It's the old expectation that she be an
object of admiration for physical looks, while fulfilling a limited set of
roles. That's long been confused with 'respect'.


Banty


No, not at all. Women, even today, make up the minority of the jobs
you describe. Respect is dying and putting your life on the line for
your wife and children. A married woman covered in a burka in
Afghanistan has more respect and value than an unwed single mother in
America. However, from the American's point of view, she is oppressed.


And you don't even realize you just said this to an unwed single mother in
America huh.

Banty


Then you should have first hand experience of what I am saying. It's
you and your child. No one to help you in life. No one to put their
life on the line for you and your child. You were some guy's temporary
toilet. Your level of respect and value is the same as of that toilet.
You go girl!

Regards...


Bzzzzt!!

Wrong on all counts. You go to the back of the line.

Banty

  #98  
Old April 19th 08, 09:35 PM posted to misc.kids.pregnancy,misc.kids
Banty
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 2,278
Default Preparing sibling for birth process?

In article ,
agsf_57 says...

On Apr 19, 5:40 am, Banty wrote:
In article ,
says...

SNIP

That is one of the most pathetic and sadist things I ever heard. I
hope you improve.


How on earth is that "pathetic" or "sad"??


That she rather have her child be raised and in company of strangers
than to sit down with the child and help her grow.


She doesn't know her childcare provider?


One person seeks advice from another person who is very experienced in the
matter. Has been happening since people were on the planet.

Your mother never discussed anything with a neighbor over coffee?


About abandoning her kids to day care and preferring it? No, I don't
think it ever came up.


Generally speaking, women like to stay home and men like to work
outside the home. It's a proven study.


Good - then you can give us a cite to that study.


You must be kidding me.

I'll even be so brave to cite a source in which the feminist attacked:
http://www.brandeis.edu/centers/cfwp/articles/6661.pdf

"New York Times columnist John Tierney looked at the study and a few
weeks ago concluded that women "want their husbands to be providers
who give them financial security and freedom.""


That does not prove your statement. It's a different statement.


No ****! They needed a study for this???? One just needs to look at
the beauty market to see women enhancing their appearance to attract
rich successful men. (Generally speaking).


Rogaine off the shelves??

Banty

  #99  
Old April 19th 08, 10:37 PM posted to misc.kids.pregnancy,misc.kids
Beliavsky
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 453
Default Preparing sibling for birth process?

On Apr 19, 7:40 am, Banty wrote:

Generally speaking, women like to stay home and men like to work
outside the home. It's a proven study.


Good - then you can give us a cite to that study.


A narrower generalization that has some support is that mothers prefer
not to work full time:

http://pewresearch.org/pubs/536/working-women

Fewer Mothers Prefer Full-time Work
From 1997 to 2007
July 12, 2007

In the span of the past decade, full-time work outside the home has
lost some of its appeal to mothers. This trend holds both for mothers
who have such jobs and those who don't.

Among working mothers with minor children (ages 17 and under), just
one-in-five (21%) say full-time work is the ideal situation for them,
down from the 32% who said this back in 1997, according to a new Pew
Research Center survey. Fully six-in-ten (up from 48% in 1997) of
today's working mothers say part-time work would be their ideal, and
another one-in-five (19%) say she would prefer not working at all
outside the home.

rest at site

  #100  
Old April 19th 08, 10:43 PM posted to misc.kids.pregnancy,misc.kids
Banty
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 2,278
Default Preparing sibling for birth process?

In article ,
Beliavsky says...

On Apr 19, 7:40 am, Banty wrote:

Generally speaking, women like to stay home and men like to work
outside the home. It's a proven study.


Good - then you can give us a cite to that study.


A narrower generalization that has some support is that mothers prefer
not to work full time:

http://pewresearch.org/pubs/536/working-women

Fewer Mothers Prefer Full-time Work
From 1997 to 2007
July 12, 2007

In the span of the past decade, full-time work outside the home has
lost some of its appeal to mothers. This trend holds both for mothers
who have such jobs and those who don't.

Among working mothers with minor children (ages 17 and under), just
one-in-five (21%) say full-time work is the ideal situation for them,
down from the 32% who said this back in 1997, according to a new Pew
Research Center survey. Fully six-in-ten (up from 48% in 1997) of
today's working mothers say part-time work would be their ideal, and
another one-in-five (19%) say she would prefer not working at all
outside the home.

rest at site


Sure.

That would accord with what I have observed, and it makes sense, too - wanting
fewer employment hours at a time of life when there are other responsibilities
that don't accord with the normal full time employment hours.

OF course, honestly told a lot of people would like to *never* need full time
employment, if the question was asked the right way. Practicality being another
matter.

But as you point out it's very much narrower than what was asserted.

Banty

 




Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Preparing sibling for birth process? Akuvikate General 187 April 28th 08 02:26 AM
Preparing a sibling for new baby - any thoughts? Cathy Pregnancy 15 October 19th 04 01:22 AM
how long was sibling w/caregiver during birth? Karen Pregnancy 11 March 18th 04 02:56 PM
AP and new sibling Lisa Besko Breastfeeding 14 August 19th 03 06:01 PM
Kiwi chiros and the birth process Todd Gastaldo Pregnancy 0 August 8th 03 12:46 PM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 07:36 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 ParentingBanter.com.
The comments are property of their posters.