If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
PTA Fundraiser - Need Commitments
My take on it is that it is not spam if I am sharing it with online
friends and acquaintances, regardless of whether or not that happens to be in 6 different groups or 50, right? Is there a specific number that constitutes something as definite spam on message boards and not via bulk e-mail? Seriously, what is the definition? I'm curious now. The main question is, 'is it spam?' Jeff |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
PTA Fundraiser - Need Commitments
In article ,
Chris says... I get what your saying, but like I said, seeing how we've discussed fundraisers in the past, many aspects of it, it just seemed to sort of fit here to me and was most unlike other spamming in multitude as of late. Correct me if I am wrong, but I believe people here have actually outright asked for fundraising suggestions/alternatives to the usual. So it would have been fine if she had posted that information in that thread, but it isn't because she just jumped in and put it out there. So - if we ever had a thread about kids' shoes, the Nike spam ads would fit in here?? Look, it's simple - this isn't a commercial newsgroup. This wasn't to help anyone - it was someone looking to make money. Banty |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
PTA Fundraiser - Need Commitments
Chris wrote:
My take on it is that it is not spam if I am sharing it with online friends and acquaintances, regardless of whether or not that happens to be in 6 different groups or 50, right? Is there a specific number that constitutes something as definite spam on message boards and not via bulk e-mail? Seriously, what is the definition? I'm curious now. The main question is, 'is it spam?' Jeff Remember when the Supreme Court said it knows pornography when it sees it, but it can't define it? Spam is sort of like that. It is less likely to be spam if: 1) It is not cross-posted 2) The message is on-topic 3) The poster is a frequent poster 4) Links on the message don't go to pages with lots of google ads. 5) The message is from Asia according to the IP. Some things are clearly spam, like the Nike shoe ads, even if they are in a thread about sneakers (tennis shoes to you midwesterners). Unfortunately, there is no way to tell for sure if some messages are spam. Jeff |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
PTA Fundraiser - Need Commitments
In article , Jeff says...
Chris wrote: My take on it is that it is not spam if I am sharing it with online friends and acquaintances, regardless of whether or not that happens to be in 6 different groups or 50, right? Is there a specific number that constitutes something as definite spam on message boards and not via bulk e-mail? Seriously, what is the definition? I'm curious now. The main question is, 'is it spam?' Jeff Remember when the Supreme Court said it knows pornography when it sees it, but it can't define it? Spam is sort of like that. It is less likely to be spam if: 1) It is not cross-posted 2) The message is on-topic 3) The poster is a frequent poster 4) Links on the message don't go to pages with lots of google ads. 5) The message is from Asia according to the IP. Some things are clearly spam, like the Nike shoe ads, even if they are in a thread about sneakers (tennis shoes to you midwesterners). Unfortunately, there is no way to tell for sure if some messages are spam. Actually, there is a definition that's formalized that has to do with the number of substantially similar (it used to say 'the same', but of course the spammers would vary their messages slightly to get around the filters) posts to a certain number of groups, etc. But the term has gotten applied to any commercial message, probably incorrectly. I still think that *any* commercial message, all of them taken in toto, even if they show up one at a time, has the irritating, depressing effect that old fasioned spam does. Witness how actual spam was pointed to to try to justify an individual ad. It affects the whole medium we're trying to use. Look - this stuff about how individual posters are 'different' or more valid than mass-propogated spam is a red herring - misc.kids isn't a place for ads, period. Why can I say that - because there is a charter. Take a look at the periodic posts at misc.kids.info, which will refer you to the misc.kids FAQ ftp://rtfm.mit.edu/pub/usenet/news.a...ids/faq/part1: ___ * Please do not post advertisements. misc.kids is a non-commercial newsgroup. Reviews and discussions of commercial products relating to children are appropriate, although they would be more appropriate in misc.kids.consumers. ___ Banty |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
PTA Fundraiser - Need Commitments
On Feb 29, 10:45Â*pm, Chris wrote:
On Feb 29, 8:03�am, Banty wrote: In article , Chris says... On Feb 28, 8:21=EF=BF=BDpm, Banty wrote: In article .= com, says... I have a great PTA fundraiser for any PTA chairs/moms in the elementary school system. You have got to be kidding. Hmmmm. I don't get stressed out at baking time, but wouldn't mind saving on the number of times I have to roll out the dough. lol. I might buy one on the shelves in the cookier cutter aisles over a single cutter. I would also take out the whole story about how you lost the contest, as it appears to make you somewhat of a sore loser trying to catch up. Either you have a great product or you don't. Get it into stores, if you aren't infringing on any patents, and just sell them. Some people would rather cut 4 cookies at a time and others don't care. I don't see it as a great fundraiser though. I don't understand what the big deal about posting that is. It isn't like she's the Nike spammer we've had here for months and months. When I'm finally able to share that invention I started last year here, you gonna "turn me in?" or is that different because I've been here for a couple of years now? And, because there are other spammers and commercial advertisers, more is OK?? What do you tell your kids when they say "everyone else does it"?? �THIS ISN'T A COMMERCIAL NEWSGROUP. �To cast a worldwide net for a *fundraiser* (thereby trying to garner funds for some PTA we don't know, let alone that larger amount that goes to the pro fundraising firm!) is ridiculous. So, Chris - you're trying to pave the way for *your* commercial stuff sometime soon? �Well, you have been around; I'd consider it part of the community atmosphere if you were reasonable and sparing about it - but, would the next drive-by profiteer or fundraiser point to *you* like you just pointed to the Nikie spam? Do you want every MLM'er who comes along, trying against hope to get their piece of the pyramid, who happens to have kids, push their stuff here? �Laundry soap, anyone?? Usenet is barely hanging on as it is. �Newcomers who would become real contributors are turned off by the spam and commercial schtuff as it is (and, can't you use filters? �Why do you even see the Nikie stuff?) How about here, and in real life, having some sensitivity to people's concerns about what kind of world it is if every social connection, face to face or not, is sullied by what $$$$$$$$ can be made? Jeees. Banty- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - Honestly, I love seeing what other mothers (women with children who are often inspired by their children or prompted into creativity upon having them to find ways to spend time with them) have created and based businesses upon, so that sort of thing doesn't bother me one wit. I believe I had originally discussed my "thing" with Nikki (sp?) way back when it hit me to get a patent for it after I had been using it successfully for a while myself. I probably would have just pinged her here to share it, as we had discussed prior, so I wanted to know how that would be treated. lol. I just find it odd that someone would feel the need to turn someone in for a post on a message board that actually touches on past subjects, but I can completely see why someone would turn someone who repeatedly posts on the same boards over and over and over again. lol. I've really never felt the need to filter and instead choose which posts I will ignore. If anyone really wants usenet and is turned off by the spam Â*- can't THEY filter? Why would it chase them off? The whole "children" scenario, well, it doesn't deserve any explanation--maybe it is just one of those things that some people see in black and white while others see shades of gray. shrug- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - Thank you for your support, Chris. I was getting quite a complex and felt like a child being reprimanded. It really did bother me. I am learning the ropes here and apparently I stepped over a line. I did try to go through a PTA "thread", but all I could find were postings from 1997 - 2002, so I posted a new one. I guess this group stuff has been around a lot longer than I expected. Having children takes you out of the loop. Anyway, my apologies to all group members. For the future, I will only have any info in my signature. I know many of you are here to help, so I feel bad that I took you away from much more important tasks. Enjoy your day...snow out this way. Oh, anything else I should know so I don't get the internet police after me? |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
PTA Fundraiser - Need Commitments
|
#17
|
|||
|
|||
PTA Fundraiser - Need Commitments
On Mar 1, 8:48*am, Banty wrote:
In article , says... On Feb 29, 10:45=C2=A0pm, Chris wrote: On Feb 29, 8:03=EF=BF=BDam, Banty wrote: In article = s.com, Chris says... On Feb 28, 8:21=3DEF=3DBF=3DBDpm, Banty wrot= e: In article = oups.=3D com, says... I have a great PTA fundraiser for any PTA chairs/moms in the elementary school system. You have got to be kidding. Hmmmm. I don't get stressed out at baking time, but wouldn't mind saving on the number of times I have to roll out the dough. lol. I might buy one on the shelves in the cookier cutter aisles over a single cutter. I would also take out the whole story about how you lost the contest, as it appears to make you somewhat of a sore loser trying to catch up. Either you have a great product or you don't. Get it into stores, if you aren't infringing on any patents, and just sell them. Some people would rather cut 4 cookies at a time and others don't care. I don't see it as a great fundraiser though. I don't understand what the big deal about posting that is. It isn't like she's the Nike spammer we've had here for months and months. When I'm finally able to share that invention I started last year here, you gonna "turn me in?" or is that different because I've been here for a couple of years now? And, because there are other spammers and commercial advertisers, more i= s OK?? What do you tell your kids when they say "everyone else does it"?? =EF= =BF=BDTHIS ISN'T A COMMERCIAL NEWSGROUP. =EF=BF=BDTo cast a worldwide net for a *fundraiser= * (thereby trying to garner funds for some PTA we don't know, let alone that larger= amount that goes to the pro fundraising firm!) is ridiculous. So, Chris - you're trying to pave the way for *your* commercial stuff so= metime soon? =EF=BF=BDWell, you have been around; I'd consider it part of the c= ommunity atmosphere if you were reasonable and sparing about it - but, would the = next drive-by profiteer or fundraiser point to *you* like you just pointed to= the Nikie spam? Do you want every MLM'er who comes along, trying against hope to get the= ir piece of the pyramid, who happens to have kids, push their stuff here? =EF=BF= =BDLaundry soap, anyone?? Usenet is barely hanging on as it is. =EF=BF=BDNewcomers who would becom= e real contributors are turned off by the spam and commercial schtuff as it is = (and, can't you use filters? =EF=BF=BDWhy do you even see the Nikie stuff?) How about here, and in real life, having some sensitivity to people's co= ncerns about what kind of world it is if every social connection, face to face = or not, is sullied by what $$$$$$$$ can be made? Jeees. Banty- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - Honestly, I love seeing what other mothers (women with children who are often inspired by their children or prompted into creativity upon having them to find ways to spend time with them) have created and based businesses upon, so that sort of thing doesn't bother me one wit. I believe I had originally discussed my "thing" with Nikki (sp?) way back when it hit me to get a patent for it after I had been using it successfully for a while myself. I probably would have just pinged her here to share it, as we had discussed prior, so I wanted to know how that would be treated. lol. I just find it odd that someone would feel the need to turn someone in for a post on a message board that actually touches on past subjects, but I can completely see why someone would turn someone who repeatedly posts on the same boards over and over and over again. lol. I've really never felt the need to filter and instead choose which posts I will ignore. If anyone really wants usenet and is turned off by the spam =C2=A0- can't THEY filter? Why would it chase them off? The whole "children" scenario, well, it doesn't deserve any explanation--maybe it is just one of those things that some people see in black and white while others see shades of gray. shrug- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - Thank you for your support, Chris. *I was getting quite a complex and felt like a child being reprimanded. *It really did bother me. *I am learning the ropes here and apparently I stepped over a line. *I did try to go through a PTA "thread", but all I could find were postings from 1997 - 2002, so I posted a new one. *I guess this group stuff has been around a lot longer than I expected. *Having children takes you out of the loop. *Anyway, my apologies to all group members. For the future, I will only have any info in my signature. *I know many of you are here to help, so I feel bad that I took you away from much more important tasks. So, think of it like - - 6 years ago you happen to overhear a couple of fellow classroom moms talk about using Tide vs. other laundry soap. *Because of that, you're knocking on their doors with your MLM laundry soap because you know they're interested in laundry soap. *How do you think that would be received, vs. being there for the original conversation, keeping in mind that selling even then would come off as pushy. This is just the kind of fishing around for openings for ads that's so transparent and so irritating. What is it about some folks with stuff to sell think it's something everyone *else* wants to hear about? *Oh, yeah, it's denoted $$$$$$$$... Have a little sensitivity for the time and place for stuff like that. *Which isn't every social medium you see. *Do you do this IRL, walk up to people in conversations to push your wares? *Prolly not. *Ads belong in advertising mediums, for people who are prospective customers to go to. *A lot of us are trying to live our lives not saturated with commercialism. Enjoy your day...snow out this way. Oh, anything else I should know so I don't get the internet police after me? Check out the group charter in my other post. *And gosh forbid anyone *cares* or they're called the 'police', isn't that what people who just want to do what they want damn everyone else says- anyone who speaks up are being the police. Jees. Banty- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - I'm not sure how much more I can apologize here. I got the point. |
#18
|
|||
|
|||
PTA Fundraiser - Need Commitments
|
#19
|
|||
|
|||
PTA Fundraiser - Need Commitments
On Mar 1, 8:31Â*am, wrote:
On Feb 29, 10:45Â*pm, Chris wrote: On Feb 29, 8:03�am, Banty wrote: In article , Chris says... On Feb 28, 8:21=EF=BF=BDpm, Banty wrote: In article .= com, says... I have a great PTA fundraiser for any PTA chairs/moms in the elementary school system. You have got to be kidding. Hmmmm. I don't get stressed out at baking time, but wouldn't mind saving on the number of times I have to roll out the dough. lol. I might buy one on the shelves in the cookier cutter aisles over a single cutter. I would also take out the whole story about how you lost the contest, as it appears to make you somewhat of a sore loser trying to catch up. Either you have a great product or you don't. Get it into stores, if you aren't infringing on any patents, and just sell them. Some people would rather cut 4 cookies at a time and others don't care. I don't see it as a great fundraiser though. I don't understand what the big deal about posting that is. It isn't like she's the Nike spammer we've had here for months and months. When I'm finally able to share that invention I started last year here, you gonna "turn me in?" or is that different because I've been here for a couple of years now? And, because there are other spammers and commercial advertisers, more is OK?? What do you tell your kids when they say "everyone else does it"?? �THIS ISN'T A COMMERCIAL NEWSGROUP. �To cast a worldwide net for a *fundraiser* (thereby trying to garner funds for some PTA we don't know, let alone that larger amount that goes to the pro fundraising firm!) is ridiculous. So, Chris - you're trying to pave the way for *your* commercial stuff sometime soon? �Well, you have been around; I'd consider it part of the community atmosphere if you were reasonable and sparing about it - but, would the next drive-by profiteer or fundraiser point to *you* like you just pointed to the Nikie spam? Do you want every MLM'er who comes along, trying against hope to get their piece of the pyramid, who happens to have kids, push their stuff here? �Laundry soap, anyone?? Usenet is barely hanging on as it is. �Newcomers who would become real contributors are turned off by the spam and commercial schtuff as it is (and, can't you use filters? �Why do you even see the Nikie stuff?) How about here, and in real life, having some sensitivity to people's concerns about what kind of world it is if every social connection, face to face or not, is sullied by what $$$$$$$$ can be made? Jeees. Banty- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - Honestly, I love seeing what other mothers (women with children who are often inspired by their children or prompted into creativity upon having them to find ways to spend time with them) have created and based businesses upon, so that sort of thing doesn't bother me one wit. I believe I had originally discussed my "thing" with Nikki (sp?) way back when it hit me to get a patent for it after I had been using it successfully for a while myself. I probably would have just pinged her here to share it, as we had discussed prior, so I wanted to know how that would be treated. lol. I just find it odd that someone would feel the need to turn someone in for a post on a message board that actually touches on past subjects, but I can completely see why someone would turn someone who repeatedly posts on the same boards over and over and over again. lol. I've really never felt the need to filter and instead choose which posts I will ignore. If anyone really wants usenet and is turned off by the spam Â*- can't THEY filter? Why would it chase them off? The whole "children" scenario, well, it doesn't deserve any explanation--maybe it is just one of those things that some people see in black and white while others see shades of gray. shrug- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - Thank you for your support, Chris. Â*I was getting quite a complex and felt like a child being reprimanded. Â*It really did bother me. Â*I am learning the ropes here and apparently I stepped over a line. Â*I did try to go through a PTA "thread", but all I could find were postings from 1997 - 2002, so I posted a new one. Â*I guess this group stuff has been around a lot longer than I expected. Â*Having children takes you out of the loop. Â*Anyway, my apologies to all group members. For the future, I will only have any info in my signature. Â*I know many of you are here to help, so I feel bad that I took you away from much more important tasks. Enjoy your day...snow out this way. Oh, anything else I should know so I don't get the internet police after me?- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - It's okay really. There are certain "feels" to certain groups that you can only get the feel for after lurking (reading only) for differing lengths of time, and there are people on some boards that need things worded a certain way, etc. For example, they might try to stereotype you into a certain group based on one post alone, the way it is worded, etc. so my best advice is to post things extremely well thought out in advance, and this is hardly a place to post a random rant that might make you feel better with any expectation of understanding in most cases. lol. At any rate, it's generally a nice group of people who are very helpful here and in many cases appear to be very knowledgable. Oh, and be sure to break long posts up into paragraphs or you'll get an eyeful like I did! LMAO. Searching old posts can turn up differing things each time you do them too, even if on the same topic, and depending on which one you try to respond to, you might actually inadvertantly post to a ton of different groups based on the posting list of the post to which you are replying, etc. Basically, though, since there are really only the usual group of people continuing to use these groups, hoping to get the word out on your accomplishment won't probably go very far here - if only the Nikie folks would see that and quit using up space. lol. Like I said, I enjoy seeing posts like yours pop up here and there, and probably because I have a similar goal in mind in my own life, but obviously, a lot of others don't. I could see what other groups you've posted to in usenet too, so either you were just starting to spread your "spamming" wings or you only picked 2 groups to share it with. lol. |
#20
|
|||
|
|||
PTA Fundraiser - Need Commitments
On Mar 1, 12:03�am, Jeff wrote:
Chris wrote: My take on it is that it is not spam if I am sharing it with online friends and acquaintances, regardless of whether or not that happens to be in 6 different groups or 50, right? Is there a specific number that constitutes something as definite spam on message boards and not via bulk e-mail? Seriously, what is the definition? I'm curious now. The main question is, 'is it spam?' Jeff Remember when the Supreme Court said it knows pornography when it sees it, but it can't define it? Spam is sort of like that. It is less likely to be spam if: 1) It is not cross-posted 2) The message is on-topic 3) The poster is a frequent poster 4) Links on the message don't go to pages with lots of google ads. 5) The message is from Asia according to the IP. Some things are clearly spam, like the Nike shoe ads, even if they are in a thread about sneakers (tennis shoes to you midwesterners). Unfortunately, there is no way to tell for sure if some messages are spam. Jeff I see. So it basically CAN be a large gray area then. One person might look at a nude portrait and consider it art, and another may consider it porn. I might look at someone sharing something they are excited about creating that they are promoting through school fundraising techniques in 2 posts differently than I look at shoe spam that comes in 14-post attacks at a time -- others not so much. When I read the "About this group" link on this page, it indicates nothing other than children, their behavior and their activities should be shared here, but that isn't what happens either, and it is a generally well accepted deviation once you are an established poster, but some might say that there is no business to discussing anything other than what this board was deemed to discuss either --- ahhh, the very many shades of gray. I can completely understand a pet peeve, however, having some myself. lol. Thanks for the information Jeff. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
A Brand New Fundraiser - Up to $4,200.00 Earning Potential for your Group! | luv2work4u | General | 1 | April 9th 07 07:27 PM |
A Brand New Fundraiser - Up to $4,200.00 Earning Potential for your Group! | luv2work4u | Kids Health | 0 | April 9th 07 06:32 PM |
FOSTER PARENT having fundraiser for organization benefiting foster children | Childsbestinterest | Foster Parents | 0 | December 9th 06 10:56 PM |
Great School fundraiser | [email protected] | General | 11 | January 19th 06 04:15 PM |
Looking for Little League fundraiser ideas? | [email protected] | General | 22 | October 22nd 05 02:48 PM |