If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Making a change
My daughter has been taking gymnastics at the same gym for 5 1/2 years
now. We are thinking of changing gyms because the class that works with my daughter's schedule has a coach that she really doesn't like. My daughter can't or won't explain why she doesn't like this coach. In general, we've been happy with this gym. I believe the quality of instruction is higher there than at the gym we'd be moving to (which is where she does rhythmic gymnastics, and is a much more convenient drive). There is one other class at her level that she doesn't have a direct conflict with (and that ends before 8:30 PM), but that would leave her with no days this summer without planned activities-- we planned swim lessons around Tuesday being her completely free day. Do I tell the gym why we are leaving? Since I can't give specifics (and I've tried asking DD. I just get tears.) I don't expect them to do anything about it unless it is part of a pattern. Liz |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Making a change
Elizabeth King wrote:
My daughter has been taking gymnastics at the same gym for 5 1/2 years now. We are thinking of changing gyms because the class that works with my daughter's schedule has a coach that she really doesn't like. My daughter can't or won't explain why she doesn't like this coach. In general, we've been happy with this gym. I believe the quality of instruction is higher there than at the gym we'd be moving to (which is where she does rhythmic gymnastics, and is a much more convenient drive). There is one other class at her level that she doesn't have a direct conflict with (and that ends before 8:30 PM), but that would leave her with no days this summer without planned activities-- we planned swim lessons around Tuesday being her completely free day. Do I tell the gym why we are leaving? Since I can't give specifics (and I've tried asking DD. I just get tears.) I don't expect them to do anything about it unless it is part of a pattern. How old is your daughter? 10? 16? Would she feel comfortable writing down what's bothering her about the coach, and having you read it when she is not around? Is it possible she's just burning out -- and using the coach hatred as an excuse? If you leave, just say your daughter doesn't like the coach. If they ask why, tell the truth: You don't know. Scott DD 12.95 and DS (who is sick today ) 10 |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Making a change
"Scott L" wrote in message
... Elizabeth King wrote: How old is your daughter? 10? 16? Would she feel comfortable writing down what's bothering her about the coach, and having you read it when she is not around? Is it possible she's just burning out -- and using the coach hatred as an excuse? She's 8. She really seems to want to continue with ANY other coach than this one. I've been quite clear that it is OK with me if she stops artistic gymnastics as she gets more serious about rhythmic gymnastics. That would be my preference, but I'm leaving the decision with her for now-- thank goodness her school has very little homework. Unfortunately (not just in this case) she really doesn't like to talk about her emotions or anything emotionally loaded. I'm guessing this coach has hurt DD's feelings somehow, but DD's normally quite impervious to the normal coaching criticism-- she doesn't always listen, but it doesn't seem to get to her. Maybe the coach said something DD took personally. Or maybe it is just the coaching style doesn't work for her (but she's been able to give me specifics on other coaches before-- there are only 2 coaches that she likes how they spot her back handsprings, for instance). If you leave, just say your daughter doesn't like the coach. If they ask why, tell the truth: You don't know. Thanks. My personal inclination would be to tell them that we're taking the summer off (which could be true), and then just never come back :-), but that's probably not the best way to handle it. Scott DD 12.95 and DS (who is sick today ) 10 I hope DS feels better soon! Liz |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Making a change
"Elizabeth King" wrote:
My daughter has been taking gymnastics at the same gym for 5 1/2 years now. We are thinking of changing gyms because the class that works with my daughter's schedule has a coach that she really doesn't like. It might be possible to ask the coach her/himself if there are any items that you should work on with your dd see if the coach has any concerns. But this should only be done with great caution, and you might not find out anything. My ds started running away and refusing to go to school when he was in third grade. I could never get him to say why he didn't want to go to school - I suspected it was the teacher, but neither he nor the teacher would admit that there was any problem. I did find later that at the beginning of the year she had given my ds a project that his older sister had done with a note that she expected the same kind of work from him. But it might have been something else entirely. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Making a change
In article ,
"Elizabeth King" wrote: If you leave, just say your daughter doesn't like the coach. If they ask why, tell the truth: You don't know. Thanks. My personal inclination would be to tell them that we're taking the summer off (which could be true), and then just never come back :-), but that's probably not the best way to handle it. Actually, I think that IS a good way to handle it. If your daughter were being specific about what she doesn't like about the coach, it might be helpful for him/her to have that feedback -- but since she is not being specific, I see nothing to be gained by telling them you are changing because she doesn't like the coach! -- Children won't care how much you know until they know how much you care |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Making a change
On Thu, 22 Jun 2006 14:23:15 EDT, "Elizabeth King"
wrote: My daughter has been taking gymnastics at the same gym for 5 1/2 years now. We are thinking of changing gyms because the class that works with my daughter's schedule has a coach that she really doesn't like. My daughter can't or won't explain why she doesn't like this coach. [...] Do I tell the gym why we are leaving? Since I can't give specifics (and I've tried asking DD. I just get tears.) I don't expect them to do anything about it unless it is part of a pattern. I would tell them (probably the office staff or manager, not the coach directly) that you're leaving because your daughter doesn't like Coach X. You might find out that they're shifting the coaching schedule in the fall, or you might open the door to being able to call them in the fall and ask questions about which coaches are on duty when. The people who manage the gym/club would be glad to hear from you that everything else in their program works well for your family. You can say that you don't know why your daughter doesn't like working with this coach ("doesn't like working with" is less personal than "doesn't like"). A good club manager might ask you a few more open-ended questions designed to look for clues to the problems that they must always have their ears open for. (does the coach focus too much on the talented kids? does the coach make comments about weight or body shape? does the coach shout, belittle kids who are afraid of falling, or not share a sense of humour with the kids? does the coach make appropriate efforts to prevent bullying by other kids? are there any hints of sexual, emotional, or physical abuse?) You can be polite and noncommittal in your answers, even if you get a hint that the manager is unsurprised to hear about problems with this coach. You can then decide how much of the conversation your daughter wants to hear about afterwards. For a kid who's reluctant to put hard feelings into words, it's a useful demonstration that you trust her instincts even without words, and that there are ways to say something unpopular and not open oneself up to cross-examination. Maybe your daughter will tell you someday why she didn't like this coach, and maybe she won't. Louise |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Making a change
On Fri, 23 Jun 2006 17:04:57 EDT, dragonlady
wrote: In article , "Elizabeth King" wrote: If you leave, just say your daughter doesn't like the coach. If they ask why, tell the truth: You don't know. Thanks. My personal inclination would be to tell them that we're taking the summer off (which could be true), and then just never come back :-), but that's probably not the best way to handle it. Actually, I think that IS a good way to handle it. If your daughter were being specific about what she doesn't like about the coach, it might be helpful for him/her to have that feedback -- but since she is not being specific, I see nothing to be gained by telling them you are changing because she doesn't like the coach! I disagree. As a school counselor, I work a lot with kids who have been victims of abuse. Often, the first indication we get that something is going on is vague. They just don't want to be with them or seem somewhat uncomfortable, but they will not say exactly why. The more kids you hear of who feel this way, the more likely that what is going on will be discovered. I am not saying this coach is abusive. She might just not like his style. But there is enough of exactly this kind of reaction that does go with abuse that I would like to see every instance reported to those who hire and keep people employed who work with children. If it's just a personality conflict, no harm done. Grown ups should be able to handle that. But if not, it will be crucial to have an accurate picture of just how many kids don't want to be with this coach, and it is even good information to know that they don't want to say why. -- Paula "Anyway, other people are weird, but sometimes they have candy, so it's best to try to get along with them." Joe Bay |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Making a change
"Paula" wrote in message ... On Fri, 23 Jun 2006 17:04:57 EDT, dragonlady wrote: In article , "Elizabeth King" wrote: If you leave, just say your daughter doesn't like the coach. If they ask why, tell the truth: You don't know. Thanks. My personal inclination would be to tell them that we're taking the summer off (which could be true), and then just never come back :-), but that's probably not the best way to handle it. Actually, I think that IS a good way to handle it. If your daughter were being specific about what she doesn't like about the coach, it might be helpful for him/her to have that feedback -- but since she is not being specific, I see nothing to be gained by telling them you are changing because she doesn't like the coach! I disagree. As a school counselor, I work a lot with kids who have been victims of abuse. Often, the first indication we get that something is going on is vague. They just don't want to be with them or seem somewhat uncomfortable, but they will not say exactly why. The more kids you hear of who feel this way, the more likely that what is going on will be discovered. I am not saying this coach is abusive. She might just not like his style. But there is enough of exactly this kind of reaction that does go with abuse that I would like to see every instance reported to those who hire and keep people employed who work with children. If it's just a personality conflict, no harm done. Grown ups should be able to handle that. But if not, it will be crucial to have an accurate picture of just how many kids don't want to be with this coach, and it is even good information to know that they don't want to say why. I have to agree with Paula. The first thing that jumped out at me is this *could* be abuse. It probably isn't. You should definitely let them know your concern that your daughter doesn't get along with the coach. They might be willing to make sure that your daughter can find a time slot that works for her without him being in the picture, too. You definitely need to let them know. It could be one of those silly things that kids just don't take a liking to someone, an innocent personality conflict or something sinister. Jeff -- Paula "Anyway, other people are weird, but sometimes they have candy, so it's best to try to get along with them." Joe Bay |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Making a change
In article t, Jeff says...
"Paula" wrote in message .. . On Thu, 22 Jun 2006 14:23:15 EDT, "Elizabeth King" (...) Often, the bad coaches are not caught because nobody says anything. But if several students are uncomfortable, the gym may start to watch for patterns or otherwise investigate. Or even find out how they can help him be a better coach. If you don't know something is broken, you can't fix it. I honestly don't know which way is right in this situation, but I think dragonlady is right in that there's also a danger of 'fixing' what isn't broken. I understand about the reaction to abuse, but, if a problem can't be expressed in any definate terms, there's a disparagement of the coach for what may serve no good purpose. Banty -- |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
The Case of Emily Clemons | R. Steve Walz | General | 4 | May 10th 06 07:52 AM |
21st Century E-Business Money Making Formula | NeoTycoon | Pregnancy | 0 | January 19th 05 11:05 PM |
21st Century E-Business Money Making Formula | NeoTycoon | Pregnancy | 0 | January 19th 05 10:10 PM |
21st Century E-Business Money Making Formula | NeoTycoon | General | 0 | January 19th 05 10:07 PM |
Manager brings change to DCF | wexwimpy | Foster Parents | 0 | May 7th 04 08:26 PM |