If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Kids are Worth It
I recently picked up the book "Kids are Worth I: Giving Your Child the Gift of Inner Discipline" based on a recommendation (quite possibly from this newsgroups, but I actually don't remember where). I have read/skimmed a lot of it, and I like the philosophy, but I can't quite figure out how to apply it in a lot of practical situations that seem to come up, (especially with my 4yo). For example, the book suggests giving "ownership" of the problem to the child, but there are cases where the child's behavior causes a problem for me and/or his brothers, but not for him, and I can't see a logical/natural way to make it a problem for him without being punitive. Such as, 4yo refuses to get into the car or sit in his seat to get buckled. I have a problem because I have somewhere I need to get (say, to pick up his brothers after school). He doesn't have a problem, unless I get angry, which I'd rather not have to do. Is anyone who uses the methods from this book willing to discuss in more detail how they make it work in practice? Thanks, --Robyn .. |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
For example, the book suggests giving "ownership" of the problem to
the child, but there are cases where the child's behavior causes a problem for me and/or his brothers, but not for him, and I can't see a logical/natural way to make it a problem for him without being punitive. (Didn't "How to Talk so Your Kids Will Listen..." take a similar approach?) Sometimes it's really hard to avoid owning a problem, especially with kids who place a premium on not doing what you want. It can require a lot of creativity, and I'll be the first to admit that I don't always manage. On the other hand it can be pretty effective when you can get it to work. Such as, 4yo refuses to get into the car or sit in his seat to get buckled. I have a problem because I have somewhere I need to get (say, to pick up his brothers after school). He doesn't have a problem, unless I get angry, which I'd rather not have to do. Could you - not have enough time to give him [favorite in-vehicle toy] because you spent so much time buckling him in? not have enough time to cue up favorite music tape/CD? (even though you hate it :-) - start a little earlier, and just have to sit in the boring old vehicle in the boring old driveway instead of running around & playing (or eating a snack or whatever) while waiting for brothers to show up? (depends on your pick-up arrangements) - start a little earlier, and explain why playtime was curtailed? (Not clear to me that a 4yo could apply this lesson to tomorrow's behavior.) |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
|
#4
|
|||
|
|||
In article ,
dragonlady wrote: Where *I* owned the problem (as in the case of needing to get somewhere to pick up a sibling, and the child not cooperating with getting in the car) I would try to find a way to make them own it, instead -- and that involved rewards and consequences that were logical and that the child in question cared about. That means I WAS sometimes punative. In the case of getting in the car, for example, I tried hard to find something that made sense: "Since you aren't willing to get in the car quickly and without arguing about it, we have to start to leave 1/2 hour early. You'll be stuck sitting in the car. If you can show that you can get in the car quickly and without arguing about it by doing it three times in a row, we'll have time to do (something the kid likes) before we leave to pick up your brother." (Or if there was something fun to do when we got there, "If you can get in the car quickly, we'll have time for x when we get there; if you argue with me, I'll be too tired to do it.") This is the kind of thing I do now. The "Kids are Worth It" book seems to be suggesting that such bribes/threats are never necessary. Their reasons for wanting to avoid them make sense, but I just can't see how to make it work in practice. Having read a bit more of the book more thoroughly, it seems like their approach to this would be to, indeed, get angry, and confront him about it according to a formula they provide, which would come out something like this: "E, I'm frustrated! I think I should be able to get you into the car in time to pick up the big boys without it being a big struggle every time. You are climbing over the seat right now instead of sitting still to get buckled, and you are making us late to pick up the big boys, which isn't fair to them or their teacher. I need to know that I can get you into the car quickly when we have to get somewhere at a particular time." Which is all very well and good, and I'm willing to give it a try, but I'm not too optimistic about getting a useful response to that from a 4yo. It's a good intro to the logical consequences I would normally use in any case. Thanks for your insights/experience, --Robyn .. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Robyn Kozierok wrote:
SNIP Having read a bit more of the book more thoroughly, it seems like their approach to this would be to, indeed, get angry, and confront him about it according to a formula they provide, which would come out something like this: "E, I'm frustrated! I think I should be able to get you into the car in time to pick up the big boys without it being a big struggle every time. You are climbing over the seat right now instead of sitting still to get buckled, and you are making us late to pick up the big boys, which isn't fair to them or their teacher. I need to know that I can get you into the car quickly when we have to get somewhere at a particular time." Which is all very well and good, and I'm willing to give it a try, but I'm not too optimistic about getting a useful response to that from a 4yo. I don't know that it's any consolation, but it wouldn't work with my profoundly tween 10.5 year old, either. She needs things that affect her directly (I try to connect them logically, if I at all can). Frankly, we do a lot of bribing with television. It's more along the lines of "If you can't get ready in the morning so that Dad can get out the door on time, you'll (PARENT PICKS ONE) have to get up 15 minutes earlier" (OR PARENT PICKS THE FOLLOWING COMBO INSTEAD) "we will have to get out the the door earlier and you'll lose 15 minutes of TV in the morning." The first choice applies to situations where loitering and dawdling and dragging one's feet are involved. The latter choice is predicated on the fact that she'll say she is ready, then at the last moment, come up with all sorts of things that she's "forgotten" to do, like put her homework in her backpack. Call me hopeless as a parent, but at least it works. beeswing It's a good intro to the logical consequences I would normally use in any case. Thanks for your insights/experience, --Robyn . |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
beeswing wrote:
The first choice applies to situations where loitering and dawdling and dragging one's feet are involved. The latter choice is predicated on the fact that she'll say she is ready, then at the last moment, come up with all sorts of things that she's "forgotten" to do, like put her homework in her backpack. This is a general question for all parents, I guess, 'cause I'm curious: how much time elapses between when your kid is out of bed, and out the door to school? DS usually is up at 6:40, and ready to go at 7 -- in fact we hold him back 'til 7:07 so he's not too early (he walks to school with a friend -- school starts at 7:45). DD leaves the house at 7:10 to catch a bus that shows up at 7:15 -- if she's taking a shower in the morning, she'll have to be up at 6:30, otherwise 6:40 is fine. Of the two, DD is far more likely to have a last minute forgotten- til-now emergency, but they are limited to once or twice a month. We live a 5 minute walk from high school. It'll be interesting to see how close they cut that when the time comes. We willingly drive DD to school if she misses the bus, btw. It costs $10, however, and she has yet to miss the bus. Scott DD 11 and DS 9 |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Scott wrote:
This is a general question for all parents, I guess, 'cause I'm curious: how much time elapses between when your kid is out of bed, and out the door to school? My husband drops our daughter off at school, and I usually pick her up. He wakes her up at 5:50 a.m., but it's because it usually takes her 15 to 20 minutes to actually pull herself out of bed. She does all her get-ready stuff -- eats her breakfast, gets dressed, gathers her things up (in theory!) -- and then usually has time to watch about 15 minutes of television (something she likes to do). Then, my husband starts to get her out the door about 6:50 a.m., though sometimes it takes up till 7 a.m. to actually leave, at which time he starts getting irritated. This schedule will completely change, however, next year when she goes to her new school. beeswing |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Robyn Kozierok wrote:
In article , dragonlady wrote: Where *I* owned the problem (as in the case of needing to get somewhere to pick up a sibling, and the child not cooperating with getting in the car) I would try to find a way to make them own it, instead -- and that involved rewards and consequences that were logical and that the child in question cared about. That means I WAS sometimes punative. In the case of getting in the car, for example, I tried hard to find something that made sense: "Since you aren't willing to get in the car quickly and without arguing about it, we have to start to leave 1/2 hour early. You'll be stuck sitting in the car. If you can show that you can get in the car quickly and without arguing about it by doing it three times in a row, we'll have time to do (something the kid likes) before we leave to pick up your brother." (Or if there was something fun to do when we got there, "If you can get in the car quickly, we'll have time for x when we get there; if you argue with me, I'll be too tired to do it.") This is the kind of thing I do now. The "Kids are Worth It" book seems to be suggesting that such bribes/threats are never necessary. Their reasons for wanting to avoid them make sense, but I just can't see how to make it work in practice. Having read a bit more of the book more thoroughly, it seems like their approach to this would be to, indeed, get angry, and confront him about it according to a formula they provide, which would come out something like this: "E, I'm frustrated! I think I should be able to get you into the car in time to pick up the big boys without it being a big struggle every time. You are climbing over the seat right now instead of sitting still to get buckled, and you are making us late to pick up the big boys, which isn't fair to them or their teacher. I need to know that I can get you into the car quickly when we have to get somewhere at a particular time." Which is all very well and good, and I'm willing to give it a try, but I'm not too optimistic about getting a useful response to that from a 4yo. It's a good intro to the logical consequences I would normally use in any case. I don't recall mine at 4 (or 9 or 11) being very susceptible to logical arguments, but a consistent denial of priviledges because of stonewalling obstructionism worked wonders. BTW, I can't stand the 'it isn't fair' argument. Things aren't fair -- so what? Life isn't fair. So DD and DS know not to use that line of reasoning on me Within reason of course -- I don't give DD 9 chocolate cookes and DS 2 because, well, that's not fair. Although DS wouldn't complain -- he's not one for sweets, really (Talk about a recessive gene!!) Scott DD 11 and DS 9 |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
On 2005-05-19, Scott wrote:
This is a general question for all parents, I guess, 'cause I'm curious: how much time elapses between when your kid is out of bed, and out the door to school? We get our 9-year-old out of bed at 7:15 in order to leave for school at 8:00. I walk him to school (or ride the bike+trail-a-bike, usually giving him the choice), and school starts at 8:20. Some mornings he gets up early on his own, and uses the extra time to get some computer time before school or to read a book he is engrossed in. Other mornings we have trouble even getting him to get dressed and eat some breakfast before it is time to leave for school. ------------------------------------------------------------ Kevin Karplus http://www.soe.ucsc.edu/~karplus Professor of Biomolecular Engineering, University of California, Santa Cruz Undergraduate and Graduate Director, Bioinformatics (Senior member, IEEE) (Board of Directors, ISCB) life member (LAB, Adventure Cycling, American Youth Hostels) Effective Cycling Instructor #218-ck (lapsed) Affiliations for identification only. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Scott wrote: This is a general question for all parents, I guess, 'cause I'm curious: how much time elapses between when your kid is out of bed, and out the door to school? 80 minutes. The kids get up raring to go at 6 I tell them to get their shoes on at 7:10 and we out in the street at 7:20. But they are ages 2 and 4. The younger one has to be diapered and dressed by a parent, and my husband and I get their breakfasts ready, make their lunches, etc. while also doing all the stuff we need to get ready ourselves. Most of that time needed because it is kind of a serial process of parents getting one thing ready at a time. Hopefully, this will be dramatically streamlined as the kids are able to do more themselves. It has gotten a bit better now as my 4-year-old dresses herself while I do other things, but she does require nagging. We willingly drive DD to school if she misses the bus, btw. It costs $10, however, and she has yet to miss the bus. -Jan |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
misc.kids FAQ on Good things about having kids | [email protected] | Info and FAQ's | 0 | October 29th 04 05:24 AM |
misc.kids FAQ on Good things about having kids | [email protected] | Info and FAQ's | 0 | September 29th 04 05:18 AM |
misc.kids FAQ on Good things about having kids | [email protected] | Info and FAQ's | 0 | August 29th 04 05:28 AM |
Kids exiting foster care lose out on state's help | wexwimpy | Foster Parents | 0 | July 21st 04 12:15 AM |