Review: Good Night, And Good Luck (** 1/2)

GOOD NIGHT, AND GOOD LUCK
A film review by Steve Rhodes

Copyright 2005 Steve Rhodes



RATING (0 TO ****): ** 1/2



One of the most controversial and most often referenced events of the last
century in the U.S. was the hearings that gave birth to the dreaded word of
"McCarthyism." GOOD NIGHT, AND GOOD LUCK chronicles the successful attempt
by "See It Now" host Edward R. Murrow to bring Senator McCarthy down. In
probably the year's most wildly overrated movie, director George Clooney
takes an extremely exciting piece of history and sucks all of the life out
of it. The movie is about as flat as the Pillsbury Doughboy after being run
over by an 18-wheeler.



The movie does work at times, thanks only to its extensive use of archival
footage, especially the clips of McCarthy making a fool out of himself in
front of a camera. In a performance which undoubtedly will earn him an
Academy Award nomination, David Strathairn takes great pains in getting
Morrow's unusual speech cadence just right. The movie itself is a real
smokefest, which again is very authentic. And the film works hard in
getting the costumes and the tacky 1950s furniture just perfect.



Murrow, who had been famous and revered ever since he did his "This is
London" radio broadcasts during World War II, hated McCarthy and used his
"Set It Now" program to call attention to McCarthy's slimy tactics. But it
was Murrow's more popular "Person to Person" programs that really earned him
his salary. He is shown in one of them, interviewing Liberace and asking
him when he was going to get married.



One of the interesting parts of the story shows how concerned that Murrow
and all the rest of the people at CBS news were with opinions of other
journalists about "Set It Now." A negative opinion by a single newspaper
journalist is claimed to have driven one of the television newscasters to
commit suicide. Of course, until the advent of cable and the internet,
network television had been used to having one consistent political
philosophy, even if the advertisers and upper management might have some
reservations about the opinions expressed.



Although most critics are heaping praise on GOOD NIGHT, AND GOOD LUCK,
calling it one of the best films of the year, I found it at best okay. What
it did do was remind me of what an overlooked and excellent actor David
Strathairn is and how much I would love to see an in-depth documentary on
McCarthy.



GOOD NIGHT, AND GOOD LUCK runs 1:33, but feels more like three hours. The
film is in black and white. It is rated PG for "mild thematic elements and
brief language" and would be acceptable for all ages, although most would be
bored.



The film is playing in nationwide release now in the United States. In the
Silicon Valley, it is showing at the AMC theaters, the Century theaters and
the Camera Cinemas.



Web: http://www.InternetReviews.com

Email:



************************************************** *********************



Want free reviews and weekly movie and video recommendations via Email?

Just send me a letter with the word "subscribe" in the subject line.

Sheesh... That's "See it now" !

/dan

news.west.earthlink.net wrote:
GOOD NIGHT, AND GOOD LUCK
A film review by Steve Rhodes

Copyright 2005 Steve Rhodes



RATING (0 TO ****): ** 1/2



One of the most controversial and most often referenced events of the last
century in the U.S. was the hearings that gave birth to the dreaded word of
"McCarthyism." GOOD NIGHT, AND GOOD LUCK chronicles the successful attempt
by "See It Now" host Edward R. Murrow to bring Senator McCarthy down. In
probably the year's most wildly overrated movie, director George Clooney
takes an extremely exciting piece of history and sucks all of the life out
of it. The movie is about as flat as the Pillsbury Doughboy after being run
over by an 18-wheeler.



The movie does work at times, thanks only to its extensive use of archival
footage, especially the clips of McCarthy making a fool out of himself in
front of a camera. In a performance which undoubtedly will earn him an
Academy Award nomination, David Strathairn takes great pains in getting
Morrow's unusual speech cadence just right. The movie itself is a real
smokefest, which again is very authentic. And the film works hard in
getting the costumes and the tacky 1950s furniture just perfect.



Murrow, who had been famous and revered ever since he did his "This is
London" radio broadcasts during World War II, hated McCarthy and used his
"Set It Now" program to call attention to McCarthy's slimy tactics. But it
was Murrow's more popular "Person to Person" programs that really earned him
his salary. He is shown in one of them, interviewing Liberace and asking
him when he was going to get married.



One of the interesting parts of the story shows how concerned that Murrow
and all the rest of the people at CBS news were with opinions of other
journalists about "Set It Now." A negative opinion by a single newspaper
journalist is claimed to have driven one of the television newscasters to
commit suicide. Of course, until the advent of cable and the internet,
network television had been used to having one consistent political
philosophy, even if the advertisers and upper management might have some
reservations about the opinions expressed.



Although most critics are heaping praise on GOOD NIGHT, AND GOOD LUCK,
calling it one of the best films of the year, I found it at best okay. What
it did do was remind me of what an overlooked and excellent actor David
Strathairn is and how much I would love to see an in-depth documentary on
McCarthy.



GOOD NIGHT, AND GOOD LUCK runs 1:33, but feels more like three hours. The
film is in black and white. It is rated PG for "mild thematic elements and
brief language" and would be acceptable for all ages, although most would be
bored.



The film is playing in nationwide release now in the United States. In the
Silicon Valley, it is showing at the AMC theaters, the Century theaters and
the Camera Cinemas.



Web: http://www.InternetReviews.com

Email:



************************************************** *********************



Want free reviews and weekly movie and video recommendations via Email?

Just send me a letter with the word "subscribe" in the subject line.